(I) - - 2 1 1 (BM ) 1). BM, (BM )., BM. BM (EPO),,. (Business method, BM)., 1998 State Street Bank(SSB) BM,,,,. 1 BM,, (Subject-matter Patentability and Eff ective Protection of Computer Programs), University of Sheffield(UK), 2002 7, ;, BM,, 2001 2. 134
( ) BM, (, subject-m atter patentability 2) ).. 2, BM ( ) (Subject-matter),,. BM,. 2 BM,,, BM. 3 BM EPO. 4 BM. 5 BM, 6. 2 BM 1 BM 2.,,,. 135
BM 2-1 BM, BM. B M 2-1 BM 3) 2-2 BM. BM,,,..,,,.,.. 3, BM. 136
( ) 2-2 BM 4) BM.. ( 4 4,, 2000. 5, p. 3. 137
,, ). 5). 6) (JPO). 7) : (1) (2) (3) (4), (BM)., (BM ). (BM ). BM. BM BM., 5,, p. 7. 6 Ryuta Hirashima, Changes in Subject-matter under the US Patent Law, Institute of Intellectual Property ( ), 2000 3, p. 27. 7 Chapter 1 of Implementing Guidelines for Inventions in Specific Field, JPO, 1997, http:/ / www.jpo.go.jp/ infoe/ sisine.htm 2001 12 15. 138
( )..,.,.., ( ).. BM.., BM.. EPO.. 2 BM BM BM : 8) A. B. 8,, 2000. 8, pp. 13~20. BM.,. Daehwan Koo, Subject-matter Patentability and Eff ective Protection of Computer Programs, University of Sheffield, UK, PhD dissertation, 2002. 7. (, Daehwan Koo, Subject-matter Patentability) p. 123. 139
C. D. E. F. 2-3 BM 2-3 F BM. ' ',. EPO. 9) BM IBM EPO., SSB (State Street Bank ) A T&T(A T&T Corp. v. Excel Communications, In).,.. 1996...,,. (SSB A T&T) CAFC(Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit). 9 T 0935/ 97-3.5.1 and T 1173/ 97-3.5.1. 140
( ),... (Internet-based shopping cart),.. 3. 10).. 3 BM BM BM (, Pro-patent policy). 1. BM. 11) BM. 12) 4 5. 13) 10 2000 6 3. 11 Richard Poynder, Patenting Sof tware, UK Department of Trade & Industry, 2001. 12 USPTO Press Release, 1999 3 Wired News, 1999 5 4. 13 IDC (International Data Corporation) 2001 497,700,000. 141
.. 14),,.,., CyberGold Attention Brokerage (USP 5,794,210), Buyer-driven Priceline (USP 5,794,207). 10,. 2. BM. 1980,.,. 15).. 1982 Diehr. 16) 1987. 1996 http:/ / www.nic.or.kr/ news/ news_20020115.pdf 2002 2 14. 14. Attention Brokerage p atent (US p atent 5,794,210) "N ame Your Price" (US patent 5,794,207)..,,,,. 15 www.jpo-mini.go.jp/ index 2001 2 17. 16 Diehr. 142
( ).., TRIPs WTO.,.. 1997, 17) EPO IBM. 18) 19) 1997 4 21,.. 20) 1987 1996 329, 1,471. 21) 1975, 1982, 1993. 1997. 1998 2. 22) 1998 10 17 Council for Consideration of Intellectual Property Rights in the 21st Century, Japan, 1997 4. 18 T 0935/ 97-3.5.1 [1999] R.P.C. 861 and T 1173/ 97-3.5.1 OJ 1999 EPO [609]. 19 JPO, Pro-patent Era in Japan, February 1997. The Planning Subcommittee of the Industrial Property Council, Report of the Planning Subcommittee of the Industrial Property Council-to the better understanding of pro-patent policy, 1998 11. http:/ / www.jpo-miti.go.jp/ indexj.htm 2001 3 13. 20. JPO, Annual Report on Patent Administration (1998). 21 JPO, Towards the International Harmonization of Intellectual Property Rights Systems in the 21st Century, www.jpo-miti.go.jp/ tousie/ chapter1.htm 2000 6 20. "Monthly Report on International Trade Balance' by Bank of Japan, "Survey of Current Business" by US Department of Commerce. 143
30.,, BM.. BM. 4 BM 1. BM BM Priceline ( 5,794,207 ) Amazon, NETdelivery ( 5,790,793 ), Open Market ( 5,740,549 ). Priceline ( 5,794,207, 1998. 8. 11) 1999 10 13, Priceline (MS) (Expedia). (Expedia.com) 1999 9 Hotel Price Matcher Priceline ' ',. Priceline : ( ), (Priceline). 22 The Spline Shaf t, 1998 2 24,, 1630 Hanji 35 (1998). 144
( )..,,. 2-4 Priceline... Priceline,,, Priceline ( ).. (Priceline ) ' ' ' '.,,,, Priceline. ( 5,960,411, 1999. 9. 28) 1999 10 21, (am azon.com), (Barnesandnoble.com).,,,,, 2., ID. 145
ID, cookie 23).,, ID,.,. 1999 12 3,,, ( )..,.,,. Harrington ( 5,895,454, 1999. 4. 20) 1999 11 10, Juliet Harrington (, ), (Yahoo). Harrington,, (,,, ).,. (access),.,, (shopping trolley). 23 WWW. 146
( ) Yahoo! Shopping,. (Cool-Savings).. (Open-market) (Digital shopping cart). (Cyber-gold). (N et-centive). (Home Gammbling Netw ork). 147
,,,,. 2. BM ( 11-66168) ( 10-222488), ( 95-250816) BM. 1) BM International Scientific 24) ID..,,. ( ) 25), (,,,,,, )... 24 : 08-201166 (1996. 7. 11. ) : 10-027036 (1998. 1. 27 ) : 2,939,723 (1999. 6. 18. ). 25 : 07-179227 (1995. 7. 14 ) : 09-34902 (1997. 2. 7 ) : 2,756,483 (1998. 3. 13. ). 148
( ) ( ) 26), (, ), (, ). BM. 27),. 2) BM ( ) 28), (access) ( )., (, ) (, ).,. BM BM ( 11-175623 ), ( 11-66168 ), N T T ( 10-320470 ), ( 10-240823 ), ( 10-49588 ), ( 9-297838 ), 26 : 7-335586 (1995. 11. 20 ) : 9-147203 (1997. 6. 6 ) : 2,804,933 (1998. 7. 24 ) 27, 'BM '. 28 : 10-208317 (1998. 7. 23 ) : 2000-40115 (2000. 2. 8 ). 149
( 9-114801 ), ( 8-180038 ). 3. BM 1) EPO (The Board of Appeal) Vicom 29), (technical contribution). Vicom (EPC) EPO. 2) BM IBM/ Card Reader 30) (technical component) (technical character)., Sohei 31) Petterson Queuing system 32) EPO, (technical character). 3) (Presentation of data) 29 T 208/ 84; OJ EPO 1/ 1987, 14. 30 T 854/ 90; (1993) OJ EPO 669. 31 T 769/ 92(1995); OJ EPO 525. 32 T 1002/ 92(1995); OJ EPO 605. 150
( ) BBC case 33) Color TV Signal. 4) IBM (T 935/ 97-3.5.1, T 1137/ 97-3.5.1), (further) (technical effect). (product). 4. BM BM. 1998 664, 1999 1133, 2000 9895 2001 5962, 2002 4239. ( 2-5 ). 1999 ( 191329 ) 2000 3 4 2002 12 18...,. ' 33 Colour Television Signal/ BBC case T 163/ 85(1990); OJ EPO 379. 151
2-5 BM ' (,,, ).,. LG ' TV' (operating system, OS). 34), 99-7001852 (1999. 3. 4, IPC G06F1760A0) 2002. 9. 4. PCT. BM. 34, BM 14, http:/ / jinbonews.jinbo.net / show / show. phtml? p_docnbr =13225. 152
( ) 95-20859 97-23069,,, / 98. 7. 4 99. 5. 24 96-42484 99. 4. 29 97-36564 97-74565 99. 11. 26 ( ) 1 99. 12. 20 2-6 BM ( : ) 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 515 978 9,566 5,388 3,616 149 155 240 574 623 664 1,133 9,895 5,962 4,239 ( BM G06F 17/ 00, 17/ 30, 17/ 60, 19/ 00 ) 153