에너지경영성과평가한 미공동연구 2013. 12.

- iii -

Chapter 에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 개요

Ⅰ. 개요 I. 개요 1. o o 100,.. o 1) [ 1] (: ) [ 표 1] 유가상승에따른연간에너지비용증가액 1 3 15 3 10 ( : ) 70 2,354 988 2,930 4,076 11,592 31,846 1,588 10 97 68 145 201 572 1,572 87 20 195 136 289 403 1,145 3,145 174 30 292 205 434 604 1,717 4,717 262 40 390 273 579 805 2,289 6,289 349 50 487 341 723 1,006 2,862 7,862 436 :, $10/B 2% 1) (), 100 :, 2007-1 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 o, o [ 2] 2008.4. 2008.8. 2008~2030 2010.4. / o EnMS(Energy Management System) ( 全社 ),., o,., [ 2] - 2 -

Ⅰ. 개요 2.. SEP(Superior Energy Performance) ANSI/MSE 2000. Level SEP IPMVP(International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol) 2007 5, 美 24, 2012 : (ANSI MSE 2000), (Measurement & Verification Protocol), (System Assessment Standard) [ 3] ISO SEP o () SEP ISO 50001 ISO 50001, SEP SEP Silver, Gold, Platinum - 3 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 [ 3] Pathway Pathway Silver Gold Platinum Energy % 5% 10% 15% () 3 3 3 % 15 15 15 Mature () Best Practice Scorecard Point 10 10 10 35 61 81 [ 4] SEP (Best Practice) 1.,, (70 ) 2. 3. 4. 5. (30 ) 6. 7. - 4 -

Ⅰ. 개요. o, (KSEP: Korean Superior Energy Performance) o SEP* o SEP (KSEP) ㅇ SEP - : SEP - : - M&V : ㅇ SEP - SEP (LBL, DOE ) - SEP ㅇ SEP ㅇ ㅇ ㅇ KSEP ㅇ KSEP - 5 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서. o 10 * o, ISO 50001 EnMS ( ) o - 6 -

Ⅰ. 개요 3.. o o, o,. o,, o, o US DOE(Department of Energy) CP-EnMS 2) EnMS, SEP PV 3) M&V CMVP 4) 2) Certified Practitioner in Energy Management Systems 3) Superior Energy Performance Performance Verifier 4) Certified Measurement & Verification Professional - 7 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 4. o 3, [ 7] 1 (3 ) 2 (2 ), (,, Tool), - 8 -

Ⅰ. 개요 [ 4] [ 5] - 9 -

Chapter 에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 주요연구내용

Ⅱ. 주요연구내용 II. 주요연구내용 1.. 1) IPMVP( M&V ),, (), 1993 NAESCO 1.3 1996 NAMVP(North American Energy Measurement and Verification Protocol), 1997 IPMVP(International Performance Measurement & Vercification Protocols) [ 6] - 13 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 IPMVP,,, IPMVP,,, - 14 -

Ⅱ. 주요연구내용 [ 8] IPMVP M&V,, whole facility (,, /) Facility Energy Managers Project Developers and / or Impementers ESCOs, WASCOs, NGOs, Fiance Firms, Development Banks Consultants 1 A :, - 2 B : / - 3 C : - 4 D : - - 15 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 A :. ( : Watt ) ( : ton/h).. B :.. C :,. D :. [ 9] IPMVP, / : ( ) 1~5% / 3~10% 1~10% 3~10% - 16 -

Ⅱ. 주요연구내용 [ 10] M&V Deemed savings Sample M&V Full M&V,, [ 11] M&V A / M&V 1~5% B / M&V 3~10%, C M&V 1~10% D / : End-use M&V 3~10% - 17 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 [ 12] A B C D,,,,, [ 13] M&V M&V M&V M&V ESPC M&V, ESCO M&V M&V /, :,, : /, :,, / M&V - 18 -

Ⅱ. 주요연구내용 2) SEP Protocol SEP,. SEP American National Standard Institute(ANSI) ANSI-ASQ National Accreditation Board(ANAB) SEP ISO 50001. SEP ANSI/MSE.. SEP,. SEP M&V Protocol,. SEP M&V Protocol, 2 1. 2. 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3. 3.5 3.6 3.7 1 3.8 3.9-19 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 SEP M&V Protocol, / [ 7] SEP Protocol M&V SEP [ 15] SEP (Pathway) Silver Gold Platinum Energy Performance Mature Energy 5% 10% 15% ( ) 3 3 3 15% 15% 15% ( ) 10 10 10 Best Practice Scorecards points ( ) 35 61 81 30-30 10 40 20-20 -

Ⅱ. 주요연구내용 (n+1 ~ n+3), [ 8] SEnPI (Superior Energy Performance Indicator) ( ) 1-SEnPI (Ratio) Percent (%) TJ 95% (,,, ), - 21 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서,,, [ 10] ( ) SEnPI,,, TJ RptPd (RptPd: Reporting Period) TJ Base [ 16] Forecast(Default) Backcast Standard condition TJ RptPd TJ RptPd l Base TJ RptPd l Std TJ Base l RptPd TJ Base TJ Base l Std Chaining Forecast Backcast (3 ) ( 12) 12 Data 12-22 -

Ⅱ. 주요연구내용 [ 17] ( ) ( ) Energy Performance 3 1 Mature Energy 10 5, [ 18] EnMS 3 (10 ) ( ) Energy Performance Mature Energy 5 1 (,, ), - 23 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 [ 19] TJ=bX 1) 2) 3) X =, b =, ) X =, TJ = ) X= B= (Ton, ) (, ) TJ = b0+b1+x1 +b2+x2+ +bk+xk X1, X2, X3 =,,, /,. 1) TJ = b0+b1x1x2+b2x2x3 2) TJ = B0+Xβ.. [ 11] (Forecast) - 24 -

Ⅱ. 주요연구내용, [ 12] (Backcast). 1), 2), 3) / n+3 3 ( ). 12-25 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 [ 13] (Standard Condition), [ 14] Chaining - 26 -

Ⅱ. 주요연구내용 [ 15] 1 ( ) [ 16] 1-27 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 SEnPI, [ 17] SEnPI, [ 18] (1) - 28 -

Ⅱ. 주요연구내용 [ 19] (2) - 29 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 3) Pilot o 10, o Protocol - 30 -

Ⅱ. 주요연구내용 o 3 Webinar [ 20] Webinar SEP M&V Protocol,,, 2, Sanity check, Subsets, SEP IFBPS IFBPS,,, IFBPS,, [ 21] Webinar - 31 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서. 1) ISO 50001, [], ( ) (ISO 50001 ) CD(committee draft) 50006 [] process of planning, measuring, analyzing, verifying, and reporting energy performance (3.8) or energy performance improvement for defined system boundaries (3.19) in order to establish confidence in the results IPMVP [ 22] IPMVP - 32 -

Ⅱ. 주요연구내용 2) SEP Protocol, IPMVP, BPS [ 23] [ 24] SEP M&V,, - 33 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서, Sanity check, IPMVP, SEP IFBPS - 34 -

Ⅱ. 주요연구내용 SEP Cert. MV Protocol IPMVP ISO 50006 &50015 MV / MV - / / - / // // /Ratio// O X X Must: SEP MV Protocol 3.4. 1. : p-value 0.1 ; Recommendation: Annex B-2.2 2. : F-test 0.1, Modeling 3. : R2 0.5 ; - R2 0.75 4. Mean±3SD 1. // MV Protocol,. 2. /. [] EnPI ToolAlgorithm( 13 ) - SEP MV EVO ISO. 1. App. B 2. App.B-1. 3. App. B-2. Modeling,R2, SE, [] App. D-11 ISO 50001 IPMVP C&D. ISO 50006 4.5.3.3 - Outlier Mean±2.5SD ISO 50015 - MV / 1. ISO 50006 EnB &EnPI SEP MV. 2. ISO 50015 M&V. 3. ISO50002 /. - 35 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 No 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 1.,,,,, 2., 3. 4.,, 5., 6., Subset 7., 8., 9.,, 10.,, 11., 12., - 36 -

Ⅱ. 주요연구내용, 13. EPIA, Sanity check 14., 1 2. 3. [ 25] ( ) 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 ISO 50001 1.5, 1.6 IPMVP: 2012, KS A ISO 50001: 2011, SANS 50010: 2011, SEP M&V: 2012, IFBPS: 2012 ISO 50001 SEP 4. 5. 4.1 4.2 4.3 5.1 5.2 IPMVP M&V Protocol (, ) (M&V Protocol Forecast, Backcast) Forecast, Backcast ISO 50001 M&V Protocol ISO 50001 M&V Protocol 6. 6.1 M&V Protocol - 37 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 6.2 Subset 7.1 7.2 8.1 8.2 9.1 9.2, 10.1 10.2 10.3 11.1 11.2 12.1 12.2 M&V Protocol Subset M&V Protocol M&V Protocol,,, ISO 50015 IPMVP M&V Protocol,, M&V Protocol IPMVP IPMVP M&V Protocol M&V Protocol TOOL M&V Protocol (Outlier) 12.3 M&V Protocol - 38 -

Ⅱ. 주요연구내용 13. 14. 13.1 EPIA 13.2 Sanity check 14.1 14.2, (EPIA) IPMVP C() M&V Protocol M&V M&V Protocol IPMVP, SEP Protocol, - 39 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 [ 26] IPMVP, SEP Protocol, IPMVP SEP Protocol ( ) 1. 1. 1. 2. M&V 2. 2. 3. M&V 3. 3. 4. IPMVP 3.1 4. 5. M&V 3.2 5. 6. M&V 3.3 6. 7. IPMVP 3.4 7. 8. M&V 3.5 8. 9. 3.6 9. 10. 3.7 1 10. #1. 3.8 11. #2. 3.9 12. #3. #4. IPMVP 13. 14. #1. #2. #3. #4. - 40 -

Ⅱ. 주요연구내용 25 10 SEP Protocol No 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 -, - - - - - 41 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서,,, EnPI,,, [ 26] - 42 -

Ⅱ. 주요연구내용 o EnPI Tool(v.3.0 v.3.14, ) EnPI Tool 3.14 Sheet, EnPI Tool 3.0, EnPI Tool 3.14, EnPI Tool 3.0 Tool, - 43 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 [ 27] EnPI Tool - 44 -

Ⅱ. 주요연구내용 o Tool(Excel) - 45 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 sheet TJ, sheet, sheet Forecast, Backcast, Chaining method,, Forecast Non-Routine Adjustment sheet, SEP.,,, MBE, CV(RMSE) Sheet,. Sheet,,,,,, 3),, - 46 -

Ⅱ. 주요연구내용,,, ISO 50001 TOOL, TOOL, TOOL,, TOOL - 47 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 2.. (Georgia Tech) o Georgia Tech Professional Education SEP CPEnMS, SEP-PV o Certified Practitioner for Energy Management Systems ISO 150001 SEP Program ISO 50001 ISO 50001,, PDCA SEP SEP, SEP, SEP Case Study e-guide Tool NPV, M&V ISO 50001 ISO 50001 MSE50021 4 CPEnMS SEP ISO 50001, - 48 -

Ⅱ. 주요연구내용 Energy Review Part Ⅰ : Energy Review Part Ⅱ : 1 CPEnMS Energy Review Part Ⅲ : Energy Review Part Ⅳ : Energy Review Part Ⅴ : EnPI, Baseline Action plan 2 M&V Protocol Part Ⅰ M&V Protocol Part Ⅱ 3, 4 Scorecard CAPA o Superior Energy Performance-Performance Verifier, CP-EnMS (ISO 50001, ) 1 2 3 PV SEP PV Sanity Check - 49 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서. 1),,, 2) EnMS EnMS 3) EnMS EnMS, ISO 50001 4) EnMS EnMS CP-EnMS EnMS 17-50 -

- 51 -

- 52 -

- 53 -

3 ISO 3 5) SEP-PV 11 1 1-54 -

2 M&V 3 M&V 4 5 6 7 8 SEP M&V, SEnPI M&V input output input output input output M&V SEP P-value, DOE TOOL, EnPI Cost center - 55 -

EnPI 9 10 11-56 -

. o o EnMS CP-EnMS SEP-PV, << Process>> - 57 -

.,, TOOL - 58 -

1) o Pilot, o 3 2) [ 28] SEP-PV 2013 12 2 ~ 6 (5) SEP-PV (3 ) Pilot (2 ) SEP-PV Pilot - SEP M&V, SEP Best Practice Scorecard Bill Meffert, Frederick Green - 59 -

. 1) SEP-PV o M&V EnMS o : 1 : 2013. 12. 2( ) 09:00 ~ 4( ) 18:00 (3 ) [ : 09:00 ~ 18:00] o () ( ) () M&V () 30 o ㅇ 25,, / ㅇ美 EnMS (ANSI/MSE 2000) Bill G r o u p ㅇ EnMS (ISO 50001) Meffert Manager ㅇ美 (SEP) ㅇ美 ISO TC 242 ㅇ ISO TC 242 WG2( ) ㅇ CPEnMS, SEP PV - 60 -

ㅇ 30 100 ㅇ 2 SEP Frederick Randy Green E n e r g y P r o j e c t Manager ㅇ, EnMS, & ㅇ15 (,,, ) ㅇ美 ISO TC 242 o ISO 50001 ( ) ISO 50001 (, ) EnMS,, ESCO M&V (2 ) EnMS - (10 ) - ISO 50001 (, 2 ) - - EnMS - - ISO TC 242 Mirror Committee - 61 -

2) o 10 o : 1 : 2013. 12. 5( ) ~ 6( ) o ( 20 ) EnMS EnMS o 2 M&V Subset R&D 2 2 SEP M&V Protocol Sanity Check - 62 -

BPS BPS BPS BPS - 63 -

Chapter 에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 사업추진 성과

Ⅲ. 결과 III. 사업추진성과 1.. Webinar o 1 Webinar M&V 22-67 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 o 2 Webinar IFBPS 9. o SEP M&V,, IPMVP Sanity check, - 68 -

Ⅲ. 결과 1.1 1.2 1.3 1. 1.4 1.5 1.6 2. 2. 3. 3. 4.1 4. 4.2 4.3 5.1 5. 5.2 6.1 6. 6.2 Subset 7.1 7. 7.2 8.1 8. 8.2 9.1 9. 9.2, 10.1 10. 10.2 10.3 11.1 11. 11.2 12.1 12. 12.2 12.3 13.1 EPIA 13. 13.2 Sanity check 14.1 14. 14.2. o IFBPS - 69 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 1. 2. -, 3. - 4. - 5. - 6. - 1.1. 1.2. 1.3. 2.1., 1: 2.2. 1.1 : 2.3. 1.2 : 2.4. 2: 2.5. 2.1 : 2.6. 2.2 : 2.7., 3: 2.8. 3.1 : 2.9. 3.2 : 3.1. 1: 3.2. 1 : 3.3. 2: 3.4. 2 : 3.5. 3: 3.6. 3.1 : 3.7. 3.2 : 3.8. 4: 3.9. 4.1 : 3.10. 4.2 : EnPI 4.1. 1: 4.2. 1.1 : 4.3. ES 1.2 : 5.1. 1: 5.2. 1.1 : 5.3. 1.2 : 5.4. 1.3 : 5.5. 1.4 : 5.6. 2:, 5.7. 2 : 6.1. 1: 6.2. 1.1 : _ 6.3. 1.2 : 6.4. 1.3 : 6.5. 1.4 : 6.6. 2: 6.7. 2 : 6.8. 3: 6.9. 3 : 7. 7. 8.1. 1 : (CHP) 8.2. 2 : 8. 8.3. 3 : 8.4. 5 : - 70 -

Ⅲ. 결과. o 2.. o EnMS ISO 50001 SEP M&V, IFBPS, - 71 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 <<EnMS >> - 72 -

Ⅲ. 결과 - 73 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 << >> - 74 -

Ⅲ. 결과 - 75 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서. o EnMS 12, ISO 50001. - 76 -

Ⅲ. 결과 o 13,. - 77 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미 공동연구 최종보고서 3. 에너지경영 성과평가 국제기술 세미나 개최 결과 가. SEP-PV 교육 결과 o SEP-PV 교육 결과 공단측으로부터 전문가 Pool을 추천 받아 위와 같은 자격요건을 갖춘 인원들이 참가 할 수 있도록 홍보하여 약 30명 정도가 선정되어 교육 을 수강함. o SEP-PV 교육사진 - 78 -

Ⅲ. 결과. o M&V,, 2,, M&V, IFBPS,, BPS. 2 M&V Subset. R&D,,. M&V Protocol.. Subset 2. Production energy conversion default factor. CV RMSE.. IPMVP Sanity Check. PV Sanity Check. - 79 -

에너지경영성과평가 한 미공동연구최종보고서 BPS, SEP 2015 BPS, 10 BPS. BPS 4., BPS. o - 80-