철학탐구 1. 존엄사법또는웰다잉법 ,. 1) 7., ),, 1), 2), 3). 1). (POLST) (AD). 2), 1) )

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "철학탐구 1. 존엄사법또는웰다잉법 ,. 1) 7., ),, 1), 2), 3). 1). (POLST) (AD). 2), 1) )"

종례 요
6 years ago
Views:

1 안락사와존엄사, 그리고웰다잉법 맹주만 * :,..,. *

2 철학탐구 1. 존엄사법또는웰다잉법 ,. 1) 7., ),, 1), 2), 3). 1). (POLST) (AD). 2), 1) )

3 , 2, 2. 3),, 2.. 3) (hospice) ( ),,.,?. 4),, 3) ( 1, 2 ( ), 3 ) ( ), ), ), ), ), ). 4),,,.

4 철학탐구..,,.,,.,..,. 5).,..,. 5),,, 36, 2015.

5 2. 미학적안락사와존엄사.,.... 6). 6).,,,,,.. ( ),.,...,,

6 철학탐구..,.,..... / /,,...,,.,,,,.

7 ,.,.,.???? euthanasia 17 Euthanatos, eu ( ) thanatos ( ).,,,. (Oxford English Dictionary)..,..

8 철학탐구.. ( 平安 ). 7),,,.....,.. 7), ;, ; Beauchamp, Tom L. (ed.), Intending Death: The Ethics of Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia; Dworkin, Gerald Frey, R. G. Bok, Sissela, Euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide.

9 ,..,. 1.,.. 8) /...,. 8)...

10 철학탐구,.. 9).,. 2., 웰다잉법과죽음의결정권 9),, 116.

11 ..,....? , 2 3.

12 철학탐구, 10) 3,... 1) 죽음의자기결정권..,,.. (voluntary), (non-voluntary), 3 (involuntary). (active) 10) Dan W. Brock, "Voluntary active Euthanasia", Hastings Center Report, vol. 22, March-April 1992,

13 (passive).,.,. 11)......,.,,.,?, 11), ;,,, A. B. Downing, ed., The Case for Voluntary Euthanasia.

14 철학탐구,??,.... (POLST),, (AD) ( ).!,,.

15 .,. 2..,. 12),.. 2) 죽음의의사 ( 擬似 ) 결정권과연고 ( 緣故 ) 결정권,.,, 2, 2., 3., 12)?.,.

16 철학탐구 ,...,,.,,. 13),...,, 13)..

17 . 1) 2)., 3.. 3).,,, 2.,,.. 3),....,

18 철학탐구.,, ). 4. 의사조력자살과미성년자안락사.,. 14), /. 3 14) 1), 2).

19 ,.?,..,. 15) 15) Ronald Dworkin et al., <Assisted Suicide : The Philosophers Brief>, New York Review of Books, March 27, 1997,

20 철학탐구...,,,.. 30 X-.,,, )..,.,,.,, 7. 16), T. A. &, J. D., 生醫倫理學, 77.

21 ,. 3..,., 17).,.,. 3). 1, 2, 3.,,., 2), 3). 17). Russell, T., Brain Death,

22 철학탐구.,,..,,..,. 1, 18).. (amyotrophic lateral sclerosis; ), 18) J. Rachels, The Elements of Moral Philosophy, 93 ;,, 231.

23 .,... 19). 20).,,,,, 19) : < > AFP ( 死因 ) 2%. 12, ) : < >

24 철학탐구, /...,. 5. 나오며....,.,.,,.

25 참고문헌,,, 2000., 4, 37, 2016.,, 36, 2015.,, 15,, 1998.,,,, 2003., T. A. &, J. D., 生醫倫理學, /,, 1989.,,, 2012.,,, 2003.,,,, 1999.,,,, Beauchamp, Tom L. (ed.), Intending Death: The Ethics of Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia, Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall, Brock, Dan W., Voluntary active Euthanasia, Hastings Center Report, vol. 22, March-April Downing, A. B., ed., The Case for Voluntary Euthanasia, London, Dworkin, Gerald Frey, R.G Bok, Sissela, Euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide, Cambridge University Press, Dworkin, Ronald, et al., <Assisted Suicide : The Philosophers' Brief>, New York Review of Books, March 27, Lenzen, Wolfgang, Liebe, Leben, Tod. Eine moralphilosophische Studie, Stuttgart:

26 철학탐구 Reclam, Martin, Mike W., Everyday Morality, Wadsworth, Pojman, Louis P., Life and Death. A Reader in Moral Problems, Wadsworth Publishing Company, Rachels, J., The Elements of Moral Philosophy, 2nd. ed., Mcgraw-Hill College, Russell, T., Brain Death, Ashgate, 2000.

27 Euthanasia, Law of Death with Dignity, and Well-dying Law Maeng, Jooman (Chung-Ang Univ.) In this paper My argument is as follows: the current law of death with dignity, alias dictus well-dying law limits target scopes of euthanasia to terminally ill patients very strictly, also does not realize properly the humane death in every true meaning of the word which is called realization of death with dignity. But not only that, it have a problem with not excluding arbitrariness and voluntariness of enforcement of euthanasia because of controling loosely ways of consent of the parties that want to pass peacefully away. Therefore target scopes of Euthanasia which limit to terminally ill patients have to enlarge up to legalization of aesthetic euthanasia which I argue for, and ways of consent of the parties have to have a more strict simultaneously Key w ords: Euthanasia, Law of Death with Dignity, Well-dying Law, Death with Dignity, aesthetic Euthanasia, physician-assisted suicide maengjm@cau.ac.kr

철학탐구 1. 들어가는말,. (pathos),,..,.,.,,. (ethos), (logos) (enthymema). 1).... 1,,... (pistis). 2) 1) G. A. Kennedy, Aristotle on Rhetoric, 1356a(New York :

파토스가글쓰기와말하기에미치는영향 박삼열 *...,.......,..,... * 철학탐구 1. 들어가는말,. (pathos),,..,.,.,,. (ethos), (logos) (enthymema). 1).... 1,,... (pistis). 2) 1) G. A. Kennedy, Aristotle on Rhetoric, 1356a(New York : Oxford