±¹Á¦ÆòÈŁ4±Ç1È£-ÃÖÁ¾

Similar documents
V28.

' ' ( ) 2 60 ' ' ( ) 50% 21% 95 ( ) 43% 13% 10 5 ( ) 24% 9% 11 5 ( ) 20%6% ' ' ' ' ' ' 1965


µðÇÃÇ¥Áö±¤°í´Ü¸é

08년요람001~016

5-김재철

<C7C1B7CEBDC3B5F95FC1DFBED3BEC65FB1B9B3BB E687770>

µðÇÃÇ¥Áö±¤°í´Ü¸é

1-국가봄-박영준(5-37).hwp

“러시아의 탈소비에트 체제전환과 러시아형 네트워크 국가의 형성”

지속가능경영보고서도큐_전체

<C7F6B4EBBACFC7D1BFACB1B B1C72033C8A E687770>

¿ì¾ç-ÃÖÁ¾

슬라이드 1

ÆòÈ�³í¹®°ø¸ð2007c01ø+±³

????좔??

Microsoft Word - 21KR_Proceeding_2009_

ADU

?

< BBF3B9DDB1E228C6EDC1FD292E687770>

±¹Á¦ÆòÈŁ4±Ç1È£-ÃÖÁ¾

의정연구_36호_0828.hwp

조재욱D)-63-88

<3133B1C732C8A328BCF6C1A4292E687770>

?0굼皐

IDP www idp or kr IDP 정책연구 한국경제의구조적문제와개혁방향 민주정책연구원 The Institute for Democracy and Policies

?6玲狙

<392EC0E5BAB4BFC12D32362D3228C3D6C1BE292E687770>

봄호.PDF

1) 이논문은 2009 년도성신여자대학교학술연구조성비지원에의하여연구되었음. 2) Francis Fukuyama, "The End of History," National Interest, No. 16 (Summer 1989), p. 4. 3) 이러한구분에관해서는존베일리스

¼Ł¿ï¸ðµåÃÖÁ¾

<C5EBC0CFBFACB1B8BFF85F4B494E5520C5EBC0CFC7C3B7AFBDBA2832C8A3295FB3BBC1F628C0FCC3BC295F37C2F75F E687770>

2 大 韓 政 治 學 會 報 ( 第 18 輯 1 號 ) 과의 소통부재 속에 여당과 국회도 무시한 일방적인 밀어붙이기식 국정운영을 보여주고 있다. 민주주의가 무엇인지 다양하게 논의될 수 있지만, 민주주의 운영에 필요한 최소한의 제도적 조건은 권력 행사에서 국가기관 사이의

Xinhuanet Strenk

12¿ù 1~30

¹é¼Ł sm0229-1


주류-비주류 프레임으로 본 19대 대선구도 예측 좌클릭-우클릭 논쟁 넘어 새로운 대선방정식 필요 단일대상 프레임의 넘어 듀얼 프레임 필요 본 보고서는 <데일리한국>에 기고한 2017 대선, 좌클릭-우클릭 논쟁 넘어 새로운 듀얼 전략 필요 의 원본 보고서이다(2015년

국제무역론-02장

*5£00̽ÅÈ�

DBPIA-NURIMEDIA

# ¸®´õ½ÊÆ÷Ä¿½º_07-2

< BFEEB5BFB9DFC7A52E687770>

<3031C8ABB5E6C7A52E687770>

歯3일_.PDF

歯111

<B9DABCBCC1A45FBCB1B9CCBCF6C1A42E687770>

大 韓 政 治 學 會 報 ( 第 23輯 1 號 ) 된지 오래다. 국회가 본연의 임무를 다 하지 못하기 때문이다. 물론 의회가 국민들로부터 불신 받는 것은 우리나라만의 문제는 아니다. 문제는 국민들이 국회에 대한 불신이 너무 크며 업무 수행 능력에 대해서도 아주 부정적으

<30315FB1E2C8B9B3EDB4DC B0A1C0BBC8A3295FB1E8C1DFC8A32E687770>

UXJQXAAOAIYR.hwp

1-2-2하태수.hwp


?? 1990년대 중반부터 일부 지방에서 자체적인 정책 혁신 을 통해 시도된 대학생촌관 정책은 그 효과에 비자발적 확산 + 대한 긍정적 평가에 힘입어 조금씩 다른 지역으로 수평적 확산이 이루어졌다. 이? + 지방 A 지방 B 비자발적 확산 중앙 중앙정부 정부 비자발적

<302DC5EBC0CFB0FA20C6F2C8AD28BFCF292E687770>

97-354?1茸劇

ㅍㅍㅍㅍ통계지식과 경제적 상상의 구축

요 약 대한민국은 1948년 정부수립 이후 60년 만에 세계 13위의 경제대국으로 비약적인 성 장을 이루었다. 정부수립 2년 만에 북한의 전격 남침으로 전 국토가 초토화되었고, 휴 전 이후에도 안보에 대한 위협은 계속되었다. 그러나 대한민국 국민은 불리한 여건에 좌절하

<3036C0CCBCB1BFEC2E687770>

지방자치시대의 정책갈등 분석

歯데일리 PDF

Journal of Educational Innovation Research 2016, Vol. 26, No. 1, pp.1-19 DOI: *,..,,,.,.,,,,.,,,,, ( )

歯목차.PDF

03 ¸ñÂ÷

<BFA9BCBABFACB1B820C5EBB1C738382D312028BABBB9AEC1F8C2A E687770>

±¹Á¦ÆòÈŁ4±Ç1È£-ÃÖÁ¾

이화로(내지)_Fn.indd

한반도포커스_제35호

031-88T300紈뵌

1-3-2 윤기웅, 김진영, 공동성.hwp

<BAF1BBF3B1E2C8B9BAB C8A3295F317E32B4DCB6F42E717864>

삼교-1-4.hwp

......


사랑을 나누면 희망이 자라고, 희망이 자라면 사회 모두가 행복해집니다.

07_À±¿ø±æ3ÀüºÎ¼öÁ¤

<BACFC7D1B1DEBAAFBBE7C5C228C3E2C6C7292E687770>

1?4?옥?-32

Microsoft Word - NEW08_prof. Ma

Microsoft Word - 크릴전쟁_당신이 모르는 남극 바닷속 쟁탈전_FINAL.docx

DBPIA-NURIMEDIA

10_윤성학_ hwp

<30315FC0CCB5BFC1D65FC7D1B1B9BCBAB8C5B8C52E687770>

CNVZNGWAIYSE.hwp

<C1D6BAB D DC0CCC1F6BFEB2E687770>

<283129C1A4C1F8BEC62E687770>


노후 소득보장 시스템 개혁의 효과성에 대한 연구

DBPIA-NURIMEDIA

< F D20C0C7B7E1B9E8BBF3B0F8C1A6C1B6C7D520C3DFC1F820B0FCB7C320BFACB1B85FBCF6C1A42E687770>

1학년-방학활용.hwp

[자료집]노사정위_토론회_ hwp

(JH)

179

February

00시작 5

1단원

202

190

<3132B1C732C8A328C0DBBEF7292E687770>

KJNWFZ concept Paper final_Korean version with notes_June14

Transcription:

245 Oligarch Siloviki

246 2004 V Putin 2 corporate state 1) sovereign democracy 2) 1 Financial Times June 19 2006 2 managed democracy

247 2000 state president 1 2005 Unity Russia 69 2006 12 19

248 St Petersberg Siloviki KGB KGB 1989 Dresden

249 KGB 3) 1990 KGB KGB 4) Anatolii Sobchak Leningrad KGB 1991 3 1996 2 2 KGB KGB 5) 3 Westernness Blair A Ruble The Two Worlds of Vladimir Putin Leningrad Wilson Quaterly Spring 2000 pp 14 25 Samuel Charap The Petersburg Experience Putin s Political Career and Russian Foreign Policy Problems of Post Communism Vol 51 No 1 January Febuary 2004 pp 52 62 4 Andrew Jack Inside Putin s Russia London Granta Books 2005 pp 66 67 5 KGB 1990

250 6) Anatoly Chubais 7) 8) KGB 1998 7 KGB FSB 2002 358 6 2001 110 131 7 Pavel K Baev the evolution of putin s Regime Inner Circles and outer Walls Problems of Post Communism Vol 51 No 6 November December 2004 p 7 8 Ian Bremmer The Russian Roller Coaster World Policy Journal Vol 20 No 4 Winter 2003 2004 pp 22 29

251 KGB chekisty mighty men or power guy 9) tendency faction 10) power ministries Aleksandr Korzakov KGB Yevgeniy Primakov Sergei Stepashin KGB 11) 9 KGB The Kremlin Lubyanka Alliance 10 December 12 2003 Peter Reddaway Will Putin Be able to Consolidate Power Post Soviet Affairs Vol 17 No 1 January March 2001 pp 23 44 Peter Raddaway Is Putin s Power More Formal than Real Post Soviet Affairs Vol 18 No 1 January March 2002 pp 31 40 11 Peter Raddaway

252 Tatiana Diachenko Balentin Yumashev Pavel Vrodin Boris berezovsky Roman Abramovich Oleg deripaska MDM Andrei Melinichenko Iskander Maxmydov 12) 2003 2 2006 Peter Reddaway Gail W Lapidus Barry W Ickes Carol Saivetz and George Breslauer Russia in the Year 2003 Post Soviet Affairs Vol 20 No 1 January March 2004 pp 1 45 12 2003

253 FSB market value Gasprom Alexei Miller FSB 13) Sergei Yastrzhembskii Mikhail Leontyev Sergei Markov Stanislav Belkovsky December 2 2003 http www polit ru 2006 1 25 13 Lilia Shevtsova German Gref Alexei Kudrin blood Lilia Shevtsova Putin s Russia Washington D C Carnegie Endowment For International Peace 2003 pp 166 167

254 segments 14) A D C M D N V I V V V G A V G R B 2004 262 14 Pavel K Baev op cit pp 6 7

255 2010 GDP 2 15) Oligarch Olga Krishitanovskaya 50 70 1993 11 2002 25 16) 15 6 4 2006 p 9 16 Pro et Contra 7 4 2002 158 180 Olga Kryshtanovskaya and Stphen White Putin s Militocracy Post Soviet Affairs Vol 19 No 4 October December 2003 pp 289 306 Arkady Ostrovsky Is Russian Democracy becoming an Illusion Financial Times February 24 2004

256 17) 18) E Primakov 19) 17 Samuel Charap op cit pp 58 60 18 2006 pp 9 10 19 4 2004 52 69 Edward Morgan Jones and Petra Schleiter Governmental Change in a President Parliamentary Regime The Case of Russia 1994 2003 Post Soviet affairs Vol 20 No 2 2004 pp 132 163

257 2001 6 21 7 1 1 88 20) 21) 20 Jeffrey Mankoff Russia s Weak Society and Weak State The Role of Political parties Problems of Post Communism Vol 50 No 1 January February 2003 pp 40 42 21 1(2002) 118-133; 4 2004 80 92

258 2000 2 7 8 200 50 30 22) 23) 22 Moscow AP Russia Political Parties Law Backed December 28 2000 http www cdi org russia johnson 4712 html 2006 5 15

259 power vertical 7 24) 2000 10 Krusk 2001 Nazdrachenko Gennady Afanashenko 1 23 3 2002 96 128 24 2000 7 5

260 2002 9 Krasnoyarsk Aleksandr Lebed Taimyr A Proponin 3 25) 26) 25 Jeffrey W Hahn St Peterberg and the Decline of local Self Government in Post Soviet Russia Post Soviet affairs Vol 20 No 2 April June 2004 pp 123 127 26 Alla Chrikova and Natalya Lapina Political Power and Political Stability in the Russian Regions Archie Brown eds Contemporary Russian Politics A Reader Oxford UK Oxford University Press 2001 pp 234 266 11 November 30 2003 85 89

261 27) stable predictable 28) 1990 3 27 4 2002 60 65 28 J Paul Goode The Push for Regional Enlargement in Putin s Russia Post Soviet Affairs Vol 20 No 3 July September 2004 p 253 1990 Kathryn Stoner Weiss Central Weakness and Provincial Autonomy Observations on the Devolution Process in Russia Post Soviet affairs Vol 15 No 1 February March 1999 pp 87 106

262 RTR ORT NTV ORT 98 87 88 41 RTR 95 72 77 13 NTV 72 59 58 25 TV6 58 32 37 4 TV Center 39 15 19 no data Kultura 36 10 13 no data CTC 35 16 19 no data TNT 32 12 15 no data REN TV 27 13 11 no data Ivan Zassoursky Media and Power in Post Soviet Russia Armonk New York M E Sharpe 2004 p 196 ORT NTV V Gusinski 2000 G

263 Yablinsky 2000 5 NTV 46 NTV CNN T Turner NTV 29) 2000 ORT ORT 2000 5 7 29 Sarah Oates Media Civil Society and the failure of the Fourth Estate in Russia Alfred B Evans Jr Laura A Henry and Lisa McIntosh Sundstrom Russian Civil Society A Critical Assessment Armonk New York 2006 pp 57 64

264 30) ORT 2000 Kursk 9 ORT 14 ORT 2001 ORT 49 R Abramovich ORT ORT TV6 Luk Oil TV6 75 1 31) 2000 2 2000 7 30 Ivan Zassoursky Media and Power in Post Soviet Russia Armonk New York M E Sharpe 2004 pp 196 204 31 Ibid pp 206 214

265 32) 2007 5 Gazprom Dmitry Medvedev 1 2000 Igor Sechin 2 Roseneft KGB 11 6 12 15 6 21 2003 2003 4 22 Sibneft Ukos Sibneft 25 32 July 23 2000

266 33) 34) 35) 33 Peter L Clateman Yukos Affair Part VII Review of the Criminal Sentence and Appeal March 29 2006 http www cdi org russia johnson 2006 78 19 cfm 2006 4 30 34 23 2 2005 12 pp 25 46 35 1 UES 2 2003 10 31

267 36) 49 37) 1990 1990 38) 2000 36 2006 7 19 July 19 2006 37 Financial Times June 19 2006 38 great power December 12 2003

268 1990

269 Russian version of the Chinese model 39) state capitalism 40) 2000 39 Financial Times September 27 2004 40 Peter Rutland Putin s Economic Record Stephen White Zvi Gitelman and Richard Sakwa eds Developments in Russian Politics Durham Duke University press 2005 pp 202 203

270

271 6 4 2006 23 2 2005 12 69 2006 12 19 Baev Pavel K the evolution of putin s Regime Inner Circles and outer Walls Problems of Post Communism Vol 51 No 6 November December 2004 Bremmer Ian The Russian Roller Coaster World Policy Journal Vol 20 No 4 Winter 2003 2004 Charap Samuel The Petersburg Experience Putin s Political Career and Russian Foreign Policy Problems of Post Communism Vol 51 No 1 January Febuary 2004 Chrikova Alla and Natalya Lapina Political Power and Political Stability in the Russian Regions Archie Brown eds Contemporary Russian Politics A Reader Oxford UK Oxford University Press 2001 Clateman Peter L Yukos Affair Part VII Review of the Criminal Sentence and Appeal March 29 2006 http www cdi org russia johnson 2006 78 19 cfm 2006 4 30 Goode J Paul The Push for Regional Enlargement in Putin s Russia Post Soviet Affairs Vol 20 No 3 July September 2004 Hahn Jeffrey W St Peterberg and the Decline of local Self Government in Post Soviet Russia Post Soviet affairs Vol 20 No 2 April June 2004 Jack Andrew Inside Putin s Russia London Granta Books 2005

272 Kryshtanovskaya Olga and Stphen White Putin s Militocracy Post Soviet Affairs Vol 19 No 4 October December 2003 Mankoff Jeffrey Russia s Weak Society and Weak State The Role of Political parties Problems of Post Communism Vol 50 No 1 January February 2003 Morgan Jones Edward and Petra Schleiter Governmental Change in a President Parliamentary Regime The Case of Russia 1994 2003 Post Soviet affairs Vol 20 No 2 2004 Oates Sarah Media Civil Society and the failure of the Fourth Estate in Russia Alfred B Evans Jr Laura A Henry and Lisa McIntosh Sundstrom eds Russian Civil Society A Critical Assessment Armonk New York 2006 Ostrovsky Arkady Is Russian Democracy becoming an Illusion Financial Times February 24 2004 Charap Samuel The Petersburg Experience Putin s Political Career and Russian Foreign Policy Problems of Post Communism Vol 51 No 1 January February 2004 Raddaway Peter Is Putin s Power More Formal than Real Post Soviet Affairs Vol 18 No 1 January March 2002 Gail W Lapidus Barry W Ickes Carol Saivetz and George Breslauer eds Russia in the Year 2003 Post Soviet Affairs Vol 20 No 1 January March 2004 Ruble Blair A The Two Worlds of Vladimir Putin Leningrad Wilson Quaterly Spring 2000 Rutland Peter Putin s Economic Record Stephen White Zvi Gitelman and Richard Sakwa eds Developments in Russian Politics Durham Duke University press 2005 Shevtsova Lilia Putin s Russia Washington D C Carnegie Endowment For International Peace 2003

273 Stoner Weiss Kathryn Central Weakness and Provincial Autonomy Observations on the Devolution Process in Russia Post Soviet affairs Vol 15 No 1 February March 1999 Zassoursky Ivan Media and Power in Post Soviet Russia Armonk New York M E Sharpe 2004 2001 2002 4 2002 3 2002 11 November 30 2003 Pro et Contra Vol 7 No 4 2002 2004 GazetaRu March 22 2004 4 2004 2003 1 2002

274 December 2 2003 http www polit ru 2006 1 25 December 12 2003 December 12 2003 July 19 2006 July 23 2000