?0굼皐

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "?0굼皐"

승준 문
6 years ago
Views:

1 :,,,,. * ** ***

2 .. ), (European Union: EU),. EU. ) (Energy Politics) (Goldman ).. ),. EU,? EU., EU NATO EU,. (biannual Russia EU Summit)., ) Stuermer( ). ) EU Smith ( ). EU Telo( ). ) Kalicki & Goldwyn( ).

3 EU (Energy Dialogue) ( : - ). (Premature Partnership) (Flenley : - ). EU. EU? /., EU, EU NATO, CIS,,, (CFSP) EU (, ). EU,.. ) EU,.,, EU (balanced). EU,, EU NATO ) ( ); ( ).

4 . EU., EU, EU. EU. EU.. EU.. ( ). ). ) ; ) ; ) ; ) ; )., ) ; ) ; ). ) )

5 ; ) ; ) ; ). EU (Gazprom),., ( ).. ),. ) (Gazprom, Rosneft),. Gazprom.,. Gazprom Rosneft,,. (, ).. Smith Keith ( ). )..

6 ) (Stern ). OPEC (Organization of Natural Gas Exporting Countries: ONEGC )., (Gas Exporting Countries Forum: GECF ), GECF.,....,,,,.,.,.,. EU ( )..,

7 . )... EU (European Integration) (Hamilton ). EU (strategic partnership)., (Hahn ). EU.., (model).,., EU. ) (self-identification) (Kassianova ) (Marshall : - ). ).

8 ; Baranovsky )..., EU EU. [ ] EU (Diplomaticheskii Vestnik : )., EU.. (Sutela ). EU EU., (Fedorov & Nygren ). (Legvold : - ; ). ) (CIS) ; ) ; ) NATO ; ).,.,. ) EU.. ) (Khripunov & Matthews ); Saunders( ).

9 ., EU., EU. EU (stability). ), EU., (Energy Security) ). EU (Partnership and Cooperation Agreement : PCA)., PCA., (sub-national) (Europeanisation) EU. EU EU. EU.,, (regions) (Klitsounova : ). ) EU Haukalla( ). ). & ( ).

10 . EU. EU EU.,, EU. EU (Strategic Energy Review) (Green Paper),, ( : - ). EU,, EU. EU. ) EU %, ; ) EU %, % ; ) EU, ( : ). EU. ) ; ) ; ) ; ) ; ) ; ) ; ) ; ) ; ) ; ). EU,,, EU ( : - ).

11 EU., EU,,, (rule of law),,. EU.,,,. OECD % %, % % ( : ).. EU,. ). EU.. EU, EU EU. EU EU. EU. ) ). ) European Network of Transmission System Operators for

12 EU..,. EU. EU,,. EU. EU (Reuters )., EU,. EU (bilateral talks)., EU EU., EU, EU. ) Gas(ENTSOG) European Network of Transmission System Operators for Electricity(ENTSOE) Agency for the Cooperation of Energy Regulators. ENTSOE ENTSOG. EU Parliament(.. ). ) EU. EU. EU ( : - ).

13 . EU EU. (European Security Strategy: ESS) EU. EU (European Council ). EU. EU EU /. EU. ) ; ), ; ) ; ). ) EU EU PCA., EU.,.., EU. EU. EU. ) EU PCA. EU ) ( : ). ) EU Forsberg( : - ).

14 (Energy Charter Treaty: ECT) PCA., EU.. ),,, ; ),,. EU, EU.. ) EU EU EU EU. ), EU EU. EU (divide and rule)., EU ( ) EU. EU.,. EU (Leonard) (Popescu) ) %~ %.. ) EU EU EU. Platts(...).

15 ., GDP( ) EU (,, GDP, ), EU ( ).,,... EU.,,,,,,..,.,., EU

16 EU,.. EU. EU. EU,.. ) / EU ( ). EU.,.., EU. EU., ECT. EU.,.. ) Gazprom..

17 .,.., EU, EU., EU ).. EU : EU.. ),..,. /,. (, ) (Nord Stream, South Stream ) ). ) Kalicki & Goldwyn( ). ) Adams( ).

18 . (Gazprom). ) Nord Stream South Stream. (bilateralism) (reciprocity). EU,,. EU....,,,,,, EU. EU,, EU. ( ). ) % ~. ) Ahrend & Tompson( ).

19 .,.,,.,,,,, NATO EU (Emerson )..,,,. EU ECT., EU ECT. ECT. ) EU, EU.. EU : EU. EU, ) ECT EU ECT.

20 ., EU. EU. %. %,. %,. %. IEA EU,,, (Emirates Business )., EU ECT ECT., EU. EU.,., EU.,. EU : (Second Strategic Review: EU Energy Security and Solidarity Action Plan). EU. ) (, ); ) EU ; ) ; ) ( : )., EU (,, )

21 . ) EU (,,,,, ).. EU. ) ; ) ; ) EU ; ).,,,, EU ECT. EU, EU EU., EU,,. EU. EU, EU (Nabucco) ) ) %. %. BP( ). ) ( ). (Nabucco) km. EU TEN(Trans European Network).

22 . EU, ) EU. EU,. ) (Energy charter Treaty) (Transit Protocol) ; ) EU ; ) ; ) ( ) ; ) ; ). ), EU,, EU,.,,,. EU, EU. EU. ). (.. ). ) EU.

23 .. ( ) (Conceptual Approach to the New Legal Framework for Energy Cooperation). ECT, ECT (Plus) ECT.. ECT.. ), G. G,, ( )..... ), ) Lenta.. / /.shtml. ( : ). ) ( ).

24 ECT. ECT., ECT,.., ECT,,., EU,,, ECT,., ECT,.,, Nord Stream South Stream.., ECT,. G.,.,., EU EU,.,

25 ... NATO,,,.,,,,, (CSTO). EU,. ).,,,,.,, ( ).., ) EU Andris Piebalgs ECT ECT ( ).

26 . EU., EU., EU.. EU,.,. EU. ) EU,., EU EU., EU., ).. (.. ).

27 EU.. EU ( ). ) EU, EU. EU [ ]. ) Stern( ).

28 ... :.... :... EU-. KEEI issue paper., &.. : ( )... : -EU.. -,,,... EU-, KIEP. ( ) -. ( ). ( ). ( ). ( ). ( ). ( )... EU. :.

29 ..... Adams, Jan.. Russia s Gas Diplomacy. Problems of Post-Communism,. pp. -. Ahrend, Rudiger & Tompson, William.. Unnatural Monopoly : The Endless Wait for Gas Sector Reform in Russia. Europe-Asia Studies,. pp. -. Baranovsky, V.. Russia s Attitude Towards the EU : Foreign and Security Policy Aspects. Helsinki and Berlin : Ulkopoliitinen Institute. Emerson, M.. The Elephant and the Bear : The European Union, Russia and their Near Abroad. Europa Magazine,. BP. BP Statistical Review of World Energy, June. Emirates Business. /, June. EU Parliament. May. European Council.. A Secure Europe in a Better World : European Security Strategy. Brussels: ( : ). Eurostat European Commission, Eurostat,. Fedorov, Y, and Nygren, B. eds.. Russia and Europe : Putin s Foreign Policy. Stockholm : Swedish National Defence College. Flenley, Paul.. Russia and the EU : A Pragmatic and Contradictory Relationship. Perspectives on European Politics and Society,. pp. -. Forsberg, Tuomas.. The EU-Russia Security Partnership : Why the Opportunity was Missed. European Foreign Affairs Review. pp. -. Gazprom, Annual Report,. Goldman, Marshall.. Russian Energy : A Blessing and a Curse. Journal of International Affairs,. pp. -.

30 Hahn, O.. Ten Years of Cooperation ( - ) : The EU and Russia in Perspective. conference paper. Hamilton, C. B.. Russia s European Economic Integration : Escapism and Realities. London : CEPR Discussion Paper No.. Haukalla, H.. Two Reluctant Regionalisers? : The EU and Russia in Europe s North. UPI Working Paper,. Johnson, Debra and Robinson, Paul. eds.. Perspectives on EU-Russia Relations. London and New York : Routledge. Kalicki, Jan H. and Goldwyn, David L. eds.. Energy and Security : Toward a New Foreign Policy Strategy. Baltimore : The Johns Hopkins University. Kassianova, A.. Russia : Still Open to the West? Evolution of State Identity in the Foreign Policy and Security Discourse. Europe-Asia Studies.. Keith, S.C.. March. Russia Energy Policy and its Challenge to Western Policy Makers, Center for Strategic and International Studies. Khripunov, Igor & Mary, Matthews.. Russia s Oil and Gas Interest Group and Its Foreign Policy Agenda. Problems of Post-Communism,. Klitsounova, Elena.. EU-Russian Relations : the Russian Perspective. in Debra Johnson and Paul Robinson. eds.,. Perspectives on EU-Russia Relations. London and New York : Routledge. Legvold, Robert. ed.. Russian Foreign Policy in the twenty-first Century and the Shadow of the Past. New York : Columbia University Press. Platts. May. Reuters. March. Saunders, Paul.. Russian Energy and European Security : A Transatlantic Dialogue. Washington, D.C.: The Nixon Center. Smith, Hazel.. European Union Foreign Policy : What It Is and What It Does. London: Pluto Press. Stern, Jonathan.. The Future of Russian Gas and Gazprom. Oxford : Oxford University Press.

31 Stuermer, Michael.. Putin and the Rise of Russia. London : Weidenfield & Nicolson. Sutela, P.. Russia and Europe : Some Economic Aspects. Moscow : Gendalf. Telo, Mario. ed.. European Union and New Regionalism : Regional Actors and Global Governance in a post-hegemonic Era. Adelshot : Ashgate Publishing Limited. Lenta.... President of Russia(Official Web Portal), Conceptual Approach to the New Legal Framework Diplomaticheskii Vestnik..... for Energy Cooperation (Goal and Principles), April,, eng/text/ news/ / /.shtml ( : ).

5-김재철

5-김재철 ) * I... 2005 11 3 * ). ..,.. ( ). (FTA), ( )...,.,....,. ) (Kim, - ). . ( )..,. (, )..,,.....,,..,.., ). ( ). ),, (Bernstein and Munro ) (Donnelly ).. ,..,...,,. %., GDP. GDP,.,,, GDP (, )... IMF GDP,