9 11
40 2 David L Rousseau 1990 democratic peace theory 1) 1990 3 1 David L Rousseau Christopher Gelpi Dan Reiter and Peter K Huth Assessing the Dyadic Nature of the Democratic Peace 1918 1988 American Politicial Science Review Vol 90 No 3 September 1996 pp 512 533
41 2) 9 11 2007 6 3 500 9 11 2 20 1998 p 372
42 2 3 4 1980 Michael Doyle 3) 3 Michael Doyle Kant Liberal Legacies and Foreign Affairs Part Philosophy and Public Af fairs Vol 12 No 3 Summer 1983 pp 205 235
43 200 definitive articles constitutional law 4) international law Kantian publicity 4 ibid pp 227 229
44 5) commitment cosmopolitan law 6) 7) 1990 8) Bruce Russett 5 ibid p 230 6 ibid pp 231 232 7 Michael Doyle Liberalism and World Politics American Political Science Review Vol 80 No 4 December 1986 pp 1151 69 Michael Doyle Kant Liberal Ligacies and Foreign Affairs in Michael E Brown Sean M Lynn Jones and Steven E Miller eds Debating the Democratic Peace Cambridge The MIT Press 1996 Michael Doyle Ways of War and Peace Realism Liberalism and Socialism New York London Norton 1997 pp 251 300 8 David Lake Powerful Pacifists Democratic States and War American Political Science Review Vol 86 No 1 1992 pp 24 37 Randall L Schweller Domestic Structure and Preventive War Are Democracies More Pacific World Politics Vol 44 No 2 1992 pp 235 269
45 9) fact 10) Kenneth N Waltz 1990 11) David Spiro 1945 9 Bruce Russett Grasping The Democratic Peace Principles for a Post Cold War World Princeton Princeton University Press 1993 10 op cit 1998 pp 369 371 11 Kenneth N Waltz The Emerging Structure of International Politics International Security Vol 18 No 2 Fall 1993 pp 44 79
46 12) Ido Oren 1 13) 1990 1994 democratization 3 the third pillar 14) 12 David E Spiro The Insignificance of the Liberal Peace International Security Vol 19 No 2 Fall 1994 pp 50 86 13 Ido Oren The Subjectivity of the Democratic Peace International Security Vol 20 No 2 Fall 1995 pp 147 184 14 New York Times Excerpts from President Clinton s State of the Union Message January 26 1994 p A17 Foreign Policy Bulletin The Clinton Administration Begins Vol 3 No 4 5 January April 1993 p 5
47 democratic enlargement 15) Condoleezza Rice 16) 15 The White House A National Security Strategy for a New Century May 1997
48 2001 9 11 17) Richard N Haas 9 11 9 11 18) 19) 16 Condoleezza Rice Promoting the National Interest Foreign Affairs Vol 79 No 1 January February 2000 pp 45 62 17 9 11 Colin Dueck Hegemony on the Cheap Liberal Internationalism from Wilson to Bush World Policy Journal Vol 20 No 4 2003 Edward Roodes The Imperial Logic of Bush s Liberal Agenda Survival Vol 45 No 1 2003 Fareed Zakaria Our Way The New Yorker October 14 21 2002 Michael J Mazarr George W Bush Idealist International Affairs Vol 79 No 3 2003 18 KIDA 02 13 2002 19 1 2 KPI 07 02 2007 pp 101 103
49 20) 1995 risk averse 21) W 2002 9 11 200 3000 9 11 preemptive action 20 Bill Clinton Dual Containment April 1995 2007 p 103 21 George W Bush The National Security Strategy of the United States of America The White House September 2002 2007 p 107
50 2006 22) regime change 3 23) 24) 22 Condoleezza Rice Transformational Diplomacy Remarks at Georgetown School of Foreign Service January 18 2006 23 26 1 2 2004 pp 129 131
51 9 11 2002 John R Bolton 25) 9 11 26) 24 John Lewis Gaddis A Grand Strategy of Transformation Foreign Policy November December 2002 25 John R Bolton Beyond the Axis of Evil Additional Threats from Weapons of Mass Destruction http www state gov t us rm 9962 htm May 6 2002 2007 6 19 26 2003 4 9 John Mearsheimer Hans Morgenthau and the Iraq war http opendemocracy net May 19 2005 2007 6 5
52 56 62 27) 2007 36 28) 2006 9 World Public Opinion 71 78 2006 52 47 71 29 21 78 1 47 52 1 27 AP Ipsos President Bush s Approval Ratings http www ipsos na com news pa presidential approval pdf December 3 5 2007 2007 12 10 28 AP Ipsos ibid
53 World Public Opinioin org Poll The Iraqi Public on the US Presence and the Future of Iraq Program on International Policy Attitudes September 27 2006 pp 4 5 2007 6 20 2 2007 5 85 77 17 77 6 9 85 6 Craig Murray Public Opinion on Iraq http www craigmurray co uk archives 2007 05 public opinion html 2007 6 20 3 2006 11
54 36 61 3 32 64 4 66 30 4 CCFR Global Views 2006 pp 34 35 23 1 2007 p 194 9 11 1
55 9 11 9 11 9 11 21 29) 29 9 11 http plaza snu ac kr 7Eysha 2002 9 11 2007 6 19
56 9 11
57 30) 21 19 30 11 2 2005 p 82
58 John Mearsheimer neo conservatism 31) 9 11 bandwagoning 32) balancing world 31 John Mearsheimer op cit 2005 pp 2 3 32 Stephen M Walt Alliance Formation and the Balance of World Power International Security Vol 9 No 4 Spring 1985 pp 3 43
59 33) 33 Mearsheimer op cit 2005 pp 4 6
60 34) F H Hinsley Martin Wright Hedley Bull George Modelski long cycle theory David Held cosmopolitan democracy 35) 36) 34 Andrew Hurrell Kant and the Kantian Paradigm in International Relations Review of International Studies Vol 16 1990 pp 183 205 35 George Modelski Is world politics evolutionary learning International Organization 1990 Vol 44 No 1 David Held Democracy and the Global Order From the Modern States to Cosmopolitan Governance Cambridge Polity 1995 36 No 19 1995 p 109
61 learning process 9 11 state of injustice state of devoid of justice 37) 37 Immanuel Kant a The Metaphysics of Morals in Hans Reiss Kant s Political Writings Cambridge Cambridge University Press 1991 p 137
62 the original social contract 38) 38 Ibid p 140
63 unsocial sociability ungesellige Geselligkeit 39) 40) antagonism 39 Immanuel Kant b Idea for a Universal History with a Cosmopolitan Purpose in Hans Reiss Kant s Political Writings Cambridge Cambridge University Press 1991 p 44 40 Ibid p 44 1995 pp 112
64 41) 42) 43) 1 44) 2 1 41 Ibid p 47 49 42 op cit 1995 p 115 43 33 2004 p 205 44 Immanuel Kant c Perpetual Peace A Philosophical Sketch in Hans Reiss Kant s Political Writings Cambridge Cambridge University Press 1991 pp 99 102
65 45) 3 hostility 46) 45 Ibid pp 102 103 46 Ibid pp 105 108
66 9 2 contextual sensitivity
67 47) 48) 47 Ole Weaver The Sociology of a Not So International Discipline American and European Developments in International Relations International Organization Vol 52 No 4 1998 pp 687 727 48 Immanuel Kant c op cit 1991 p 96
68 49) 49 Ibid pp 102 108
69 200
70 50) 50 1976
71 23 1 2007 19 1995 33 2004 26 1 2 2004 1 2 KPI 07 02 2007 20 1998 11 2 2005 9 11 http plaza snu ac kr 7Eysha 2002 9 11 2007 6 19 KIDA 02 13 2002 Bolton John R Beyond the Axis of Evil Additional Threats from Weapons of Mass Destruction http www state gov t us rm 9962 htm May 6 2002 2007 6 19 Brown Michael E Sean M Lynn Jones and Steven E Miller eds Debating the Democratic Peace Cambridge The MIT Press 1996 Bush George W The National Security Strategy of the United States of America The White House September 2002 CCFR Global Views 2006 Clinton Bill Dual Containment April 1995 Doyle Michael W Kant Liberal Legacies and Foreign Affairs
72 Philosophy of Public Affairs Vol 12 No 3 Summer 1983 Liberalism and World Politics American Political Science Review Vol 80 No 4 December 1986 Ways of War and Peace Realism Liberalism and Socialism New York London Norton 1997 Dueck Colin Hegemony on the Cheap Liberal Internationalism from Wilson to Bush World Policy Journal Vol 20 No 4 2003 Foreign Policy Bulletin The Clinton Administration Begins Vol 3 No 4 5 January April 1993 Gaddis John Lewis A Grand Strategy of Transformation Foreign Policy November December 2002 Held David Democracy and the Global Order From the Modern States to Cosmopolitan Governance Cambridge Polity 1995 Hurrell Andrew Kant and the Kantian Paradigm in International Relations Review of International Studies Vol 16 1990 Kant Immanuel The Metaphysics of Morals in Hans Reiss eds Kant s Political Writings Cambridge Cambridge University Press 1991 Perpetual Peace A Philosophical Sketch in Hans Reiss eds Kant s Political Writings Cambridge Cambridge University Press 1991 Idea for a Universal History with a Cosmopolitan Purpose in Hans Reiss eds Kant s Political Writings Cambridge Cambridge University Press 1991 Lake David Powerful Pacifists Democratic States and War American Political Science Review Vol 86 No 1 1992 Mazarr Michael J George W Bush Idealist International Affairs Vol 79 No 3 2003
73 Mearsheimer John Hans Morgenthau and the Iraq war http opendemocracy net May 19 200 2007 6 5 Modelski George Is world politics evolutionary learning International Organization 1990 vol 44 no 1 Murray Craig Public Opinion on Iraq http www craigmurray co uk archives 2007 05 public opinion html 2007 6 20 New York Times Excerpts from President Clinton s State of the Union Message January 26 1994 Oren Ido The Subjectivity of the Democratic Peace International Security Vol 20 No 2 Fall 1995 Rice Condoleezza Promoting the National Interest Foreign Affairs Vol 79 No 1 January February 2000 Transformational Diplomacy Remarks at Georgetown School of Foreign Service January 18 2006 Roodes Edward The Imperial Logic of Bush s Liberal Agenda Survival Vol 45 No 1 2003 Rousseau David L Christopher Gelpi Dan Reiter and Peter K Huth Assessing the Dyadic Nature of the Democratic Peace 1918 1988 American Politicial Science Review Vol 90 No 3 September 1996 Russett Bruce Grasping The Democratic Peace Principles for a Post Cold War World Princeton Princeton University Press 1993 Schweller Randall L Domestic Structure and Preventive War Are Democracies More Pacific World Politics Vol 44 No 2 1992 Spiro David E The Insignificance of the Liberal Peace International Security Vol 19 No 2 Fall 1994 The White House A National Security Strategy for a New Century May 1997
74 Walt Stephen M Alliance Formation and the Balance of World Power International Security Vol 9 No 4 Spring 1985 pp 3 43 Waltz Kenneth N The Emerging Structure of International Politics International Security Vol 18 No 2 Fall 1993 Weaver Ole The Sociology of a Not So International Discipline American and European Developments in International Relations International Organization Vol 52 No 4 1998 World Public Opinioin org Poll The Iraqi Public on the US Presence and the Future of Iraq Program on International Policy Attitudes September 27 2006 Zakaria Fareed Our Way The New Yorker October 2002