DBPIA-NURIMEDIA

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "DBPIA-NURIMEDIA"

소민 백
6 years ago
Views:

반공개발국가를넘어평화복지국가로 - 역사와전망 From Anticommunist Developmental State to the Peace-Welfare State - History and Prospective - 저자 (Authors) 출처 (Source) 발행처 (Publisher) URL 윤홍식 Yoon, Hong Sik 시민과세계, (27),

이용정보 (Accessed) 창신대학교 221.161.20.*** 2018/09/04 15:26 (KST) 저작권안내 DBpia에서제공되는모든저작물의저작권은원저작자에게있으며, 누리미디어는각저작물의내용을보증하거나책임을지지않습니다. 그리고 DBpia에서제공되는저작물은 DBpia와구독계약을체결한기관소속이용자혹은해당저작물의개별구매자가비영리적으로만이용할수있습니다.

1 반공개발국가를넘어평화복지국가로 - 역사와전망 From Anticommunist Developmental State to the Peace-Welfare State - History and Prospective - 저자 (Authors) 출처 (Source) 발행처 (Publisher) URL 윤홍식 Yoon, Hong Sik 시민과세계, (27), , (50 pages) Ctizen&the World, (27), , (50 pages) 참여연대참여사회연구소 APA Style 윤홍식 (2015). 반공개발국가를넘어평화복지국가로. 시민과세계, (27), 이용정보 (Accessed) 창신대학교 *** 2018/09/04 15:26 (KST) 저작권안내 DBpia에서제공되는모든저작물의저작권은원저작자에게있으며, 누리미디어는각저작물의내용을보증하거나책임을지지않습니다. 그리고 DBpia에서제공되는저작물은 DBpia와구독계약을체결한기관소속이용자혹은해당저작물의개별구매자가비영리적으로만이용할수있습니다. 그러므로이에위반하여 DBpia에서제공되는저작물을복제, 전송등의방법으로무단이용하는경우관련법령에따라민, 형사상의책임을질수있습니다. Copyright Information Copyright of all literary works provided by DBpia belongs to the copyright holder(s)and Nurimedia does not guarantee contents of the literary work or assume responsibility for the same. In addition, the literary works provided by DBpia may only be used by the users affiliated to the institutions which executed a subscription agreement with DBpia or the individual purchasers of the literary work(s)for non-commercial purposes. Therefore, any person who illegally uses the literary works provided by DBpia by means of reproduction or transmission shall assume civil and criminal responsibility according to applicable laws and regulations.

2 , 2015 ( 27 ) Journal of Citizen & World 2015, Vol. 27, pp : , *,, hsyoon@inha.ac.kr

3 1. 문제제기 : 왜평화복지국가인가? GDP 10.4%,, (OECD 2015, 2014). 1),,,,.??.,.., ). 1) (USD 34,356, 10.4%), (USD 33,720, 26.8%), (USD 35,067, 28.6%), (USD 36,402, 20.8%), (USD 26,016, 24.0%), (USD 28,317, 25.2%), (USD 29,969, 23.7%), (USD 24,466, 22.1%), (USD 26,902, 16.3%), (USD 19,054, 12.5%). 2).

4 ,, ,..,...,... 3) 3)

5 .,.,.,,. 2,, 반공개발국가의기원과궤적?... 2,,..

6 (2015, 292) ( ),, ( 2013).. (Cumings 1974) %. 94%, 80~90%. 35% %, 18.3% ( 2007, 45) , ( 2004, 29)..

7 ( 1989; 1999, 336; Cumings 1983, 139). ( ) (Smith 2007[1973]).,., ( ) (Cumings 2001[1997], 219). ( ), ,,....., ( ) ( 1989). ( )

8 .,, ( 2008, 23). 4), ( 2013) ) 4) 48. (54) 48, 48., ( 2014, 63). 5) (2008, 137) 5 (1963 ) ( )..

9 1920 ( ) ( ) ( ) %, 14% ( ). 3%, 85% ( ),. 7) 1917 ( ) ( ) (Berman 2010[2006], 20).,.,.... 6)... 7)

10 ( 3 ), (Brandal, Bratberg and Thorsen 2014[2013], 5-6, 74-5).. ( ), ( ). (Smith 2007[1973], 84). ( ) ( ).,, ( ) (Sassoon 2014; 1992).. 3.

11 . ( 1994, 157). ( ) 3 ( ). 27 ( 1995) ( 2013, 15-7) ( ).., (timing)., % (Sassoon 2014; 1992).

12 ( 1994, 159) ( ) , 3 ( ).. ( ) ( 2000). 8) ( ), (timing).,. 8). (2005).. :.

13 1 2.., 1927 (Christopher Hornsrud). 18. (Brandal et. al. 2014[2013], 87). ( 2013a, 522)..... ( 1994, 166). 1925,, ( 1994; 1994). ( ) ( 2013a, 550-1; 1994, 182).. ( ) ( )..,

14 . 1920,. (Smith 2007[1973], 31-2)., (Smith 2007[1973], 92-3). ( 2013b, 283),... ( ) ,, 1962 ( 2015, 160; 2008, 104, 137) (Arrighi, Ahmadand and Shin 2008[1999]; Arrighi 2008[1994]). 19, 1945 ( ).

15 ,,. ( ). (Moore 1966).. (2015, 323),. ( ) ( ) ( 2015, 322) ,,

16 ( ) ( ), ( ). (Berger 2004; Dobbins, McGinn, Jones, Lal, Rathmell, Swanger and Timilsina 2003, xiv). (2003a) ).. (Moore 1966)., 1878 ( ). ( ) ( ). ( ) (Ritter 2005[1983]). 9).. (2003a).., :, pp :.

17 (Silver and Slater 2008[1999], 297).. (Ritter 2005[1983]; Stolleis 2013)., 1870.,.. 1 (Duus 1983[1976], 194-6) ,388. ( ) ) 10) 4

18 ,...??. (2003a, 51).. (2003b)...,.... ( ) (developmental economics). (Millikan and Rowstow 1957) (underdeveloped nations) (Geoff Eley), (Eley 1984, 62-74). ( 2013a, ; 1994, ).

19 3.,...,, ( ).,....,.. 11) (2015), (Holliday 2000) (Andersson 2014). 11) ( ).

20 (Gunnar Myrdal) ( ), (Samordnad näringspolitik) (Resultat och reformer) (Arbeit und brot), (arbete åt alla), (Ökad Köpkraft) ( ~ ) ( 2003). 12) ( 2003) ) 1961 ( 2003, 141). 4,....

21 2.1% % ( 2005, 193)... ( 2003a). 3. 한국반공개발국가와복지국가 ( )., ( ) ( ) ( 5 ) ( 2003, 192-3) ( ) 1

22 5 ( 1 ) 1 ( ).. 1.,, ( 2003, 200-1) , %. ( 2003, 132) % ( 2005, 138).. (1996, 237)

23 1950. (2014, 27) 1950 ( 1.0).. 1 (1962~1966) 7.9%.. (2003a, 48).,. (Johnson) (Johnson 1994, 43)., (2006[2003]) %

24 ( 2003, 142) ,,. 13) 5 (1962 ~1971 ) 8.7% ( 2000) , , ,, 6, 7 28, 8 10, 9 15 KAL ( ), 12 6, , 10..,.,,,,., (Johnson 1994), 13) (2004).

25 ( 2007, 33).,.. ( 2015) (Wallerstein, 2005[2004]) (promotion by invitation) ),,, ( ) ( ) ( 1988, 20-1; 2007, 414) ( ) 35.2% ( 2013, 469) ), ( 2006, 72).

26 ( 2013, 459) ( 2003). ( ) % 21.8%. 7.3% 26.6%., (General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade) 3 ( 2006).. 3,., ( 2011, ). 15) 15) % ( 2011, 160)

27 , 6 ( 2009, 161) ( 2007).. ( 2003) , (Schwartz 2015[2010]) , ( 2007, 414; 2006, 81).

28 ,, (Multi- Fiber Arrangement: MFA) ( 1992; 1978). 16). ( 2003). 17) GDP 2.7% ( 2012, 12)... 18),,, 16) (WTO) (Agreement on Textile and Clothing: ATC) ( 2005, 77). 17) (2006, 84-5) 1969, EEC,, ( ). 18).

29 ( 2014, 226)... 3 ( 2009, 31) , (Evans 1995) ( ). 19) 1960 (1949~ 1953) ( ) ( 2011, 147)..,, ( 2013). ( ) (Wade 1990)... ( ) ( ) (Amsden 1986). 19).

30 ( 2006[2003], 234). (2006[2003], 104), ,,,,, , ( 2005, 192) (Amsden 1989)...., 1960 (Donbusch and Park 1987, 405). 1960,..

31 .,,,. (2000, 124-5)..... (1993, 51) % (1 GNP USD 2,370) (1 GNP USD 1,890) 22.4%. (1 GNP USD 750) 13.1% (1 GNP USD 200) 9.8%.?.. (2015, 176)

32 ,..., 1876 ( )., 4 19 ( 1989, 95-7; 2005, ) 20).,,,. ( ) (1961~1987) GDP 2% ( 1992; 1999; 2008; OECD 2015) GDP 5%.. (2014, 8) %, % %, %. (2015, 140-1) 20).,,,,,,, ( 1986, 96).

33 1% 17% %. 1% ( 1992; 1999; 2008) GDP. 21) (1993)... GDP GDP (, ; World Bank 2015; 2011)., GDP. 21) % %, % ( 2003, 231). 38.0%, 40.9%, 44.1% , ,700..

34 ..,,. 1993, ( ).. 4. 반공개발국가의대안으로서평화복지국가?.,.,.

35 1997,. 10. ( )......,......,, 1990 ( 2015; 2015; 2015).,

36 % ( ) ( 2015, 247).. ( 2014).. (2012) OECD ( 2015, 152). 22) % % 13.0%. ( ) OECD ( 2015, 84) NLL ( 2013, 15).. ( ) 90% ( ), 22) OECD.

37 .. ( ).,, ( ).,,., ( ), ( ) ( )...

38 ? ( ) ( )., ( ) ( ).,.. (Provisoriska utopie) , 21.?,,.,., ( )

39 ( ).,.,.. 23),. ( 2010; 2013; 2009) ( 2013)..,. 23) , ,

40 .. ( ).?.. ( ). ( )...,. ( ).,,,

41 ,,,,,,,.., ,,,,,,,,, (Sasson 2014[2014], 66; Thompson 1966, 610, 771).,, , ( ),

42 . 5. 정리및함의 (Sasson 2014)

43 .., ( ),...,,,,,....

44 ..,,.. ( ).....,,,,. ( )....,. 1945

45 . 참고문헌 : , :, : : ,,.,, : , - 48.,,, : , 2(1) ,, :,,.. 20(1) a. 2. : b. 3. : , 2. : , , 18(2) , :,, : (2) (1).

46 :. : ,,. : (2) (1) ,,. : (2) : (II). : , 2. : : : : , 5: ( ): ( ). : : : ,

47 :,. : ?.,,. : :. : (3) a.., :. : b :. : , :,. : ,. : , 15: 1, pp : , 15: 1. : [2003].. (Globalization, economic development, and the role of the state). : ). (MFA) :..

48 ,.,,. : : : : e ,. : (1) 90% ( : :06), &code=910402( : ) :. ( ) : Amsden, A Asia s next giant: South Korea and late industrialization. New York: Oxford University Press. Andersson, J. 2014[2006]. :,.. :. Arrighi, G. 2008[1994]. 20 :,,., (The long twentieth century: Money, power, and the origins of our times). :. Arrighi, G., Ahmad, I., and Shin, M. 2008[1999].. Arrighi, G., Siver, B., Hui, P. Ray, K., Reifer, T., Barr, K., Hisaeda, S., Slater, E., Ahmad, I., and Shih, M.. (Chaos and governance in the modern world system). :.

49 Berman, S. 2010[2006]. : 20. (The primacy of politics). :. Brandal, N., Bratberg, Ø., and Thorsen, D. 2014[2013].. (Nordic model of social democracy). :. Choo, H. J Income distribution and distributive equity in Korea. In L. Krause and F. Park, eds., Social Issues in Korea. Seoul: KDI. Cumings, B ,. :. Cumings, B. 2001[1997]., (Korea s place in the sun: A modern history). :. Cumings. B American policy and Korean liberation. in Balwin. F. (ed.). The American Korean Relationship Since New York: Pantheon Books. Dobbins, J., McGinn, J., Crane, K., Jones, S., Lal, R., Rathmell, A., Swanger, R., and Timilsina, A America s role in nation-building: From Germany to Iraq. Santa Monica, CA: RAND. Berger, M The battle for Aisa: From decolonization to globalization. New York, NY: RoutledgeCurzon. Donbusch, R. and Park, Y. C Korean growth policy. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 2. Duus, P. 1983[1976].., :. Eley, G The British model and the German road: Rethinking the course of German history before In D. Blackbourn and G. Eley, The peculiarities of German history: Bourgeois society and politics in nineteenth-century Germany. New York: Oxford University Press. Evans, P Embeded autonomy: State and industrial transformation. NJ: Princeton University Press. Holliday, I Productivist welfare capitalism: Social policy in East Asia. Political Studies, 48. Johnson, C What is the best system of national economic management for Korea? Cho, L. and Kim, Y. (eds.), Korea s political economy: An institutional perspective. San Francisco: Westview Press. Moore, B Social origins of dictatorship and democracy: Lord and peasant in the making of the modern world. Boston: Beacon Press. OECD Social Expenditure: Aggregated data.

50 =SOCX_AGG. OECD Society at a glance 2014: OECD social indicatores. Paris. OECD. Ritter, G. 2005[1983].. (Sozialversicherung in Deutschland und England). :. Sassoon, D. 2014[2014] 100 : 20. (One hundred years of socialism: The West European left in the twentieth century, 2014 ed.). :. Schwartz, H. 2015[2010]. :., (Limited title under states versus markets). :. Silver, B. and Slater, E. 2008[1999].. Arrighi, G., Siver, B., Hui, P. Ray, K., Reifer, T., Barr, K., Hisaeda, S., Slater, E., Ahmad, I., and Shih, M.. (Chaos and governance in the modern world system). :. Smith, D. 2007[1973]. 20,, (Left and right in twentieth century Europ: Seminar studies in history). :. Stolleis, M Origins of the German welfare state: Social policy in Germany to German Social Policy, 2. Thompson, E. P. 1966[1963]. The making of the English working class. New York, NY: Vintage Book. Wade, R Governing the market: Economic theory and the role of government in East Asian Industrialization. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Wallerstein, I. 2005[2004].. (World-system analysis: An introduction). :. World Bank Data: Korea, Rep.

51 From Anticommunist Developmental State to the Peace-Welfare State: History and Prospective This study presents the argument on why the Republic of Korea has to transfer from the Anticommunist Developmental State(ADS) to the Peace-Welfare State(PWS). The main argument is that using divided countries as the rationale, the past dictatorial anticommunist developmental state effectively suppressed the political empowerment of the labor class and the social democratic parties which are the most important agents of welfare state construction in Korea. Historically, the division of Korean peninsula did not only suppress the political empowerment of the working class and the social democratic parties but also undermined the class solidarity between the working class and the middle class in Korea. Furthermore, this study pays attention to the needs that the past (dictatorial) anticommunist developmental state provided the basis for the growth of pease and welfare state in South Korea. This study argues that Korea has to be the Pease-Welfare State although some imperfect factors remain such as border issues with North Korea and the power relation in the South Korea. Key words : the Peace-Welfare State, Developmental State, Anticommunist Developmental State, Welfare State.

DBPIA-NURIMEDIA

DBPIA-NURIMEDIA 스마트시티의재해회복력향상을위한고찰 - 동일본대지진데이터분석을중심으로 A Study on improvement for disaster resilience of the smart city - Mainly on the data analysis in Great East Japan Earthquake - 저자 (Authors) 장혜정, 김도년 Hye-Jung Chang,