군장병의사회복지분야공헌활성화방안에대한탐색적연구 군장병의사회복지분야공헌활성화방안에대한 탐색적연구 : 경기도포천지역사례를중심으로 민효상 *, 우지희 **, 서정욱 *** 1) Ⅰ. 서론 Ⅱ. 이론적논의및기존연구검토 Ⅲ. 연구설계 Ⅳ. 분석결과및논의 Ⅴ. 결론 Abstract Explanatory Study on Vitalizing Soldiers Social Contribution and talent Donation Activities Since the 1990s, individual s social contribution, so-called talent donation, and volunteering have gradually gained public attention in Korea. Currently, many individuals and corporations do volunteer work in the private sector. With such changes within the South Korean society, this study conducts an analysis for vitalizing solders social contribution. First, this article uses AHP method to understand needs of welfare services in the local communities. This study also conducts a survey to understand soldier s interest in social contribution or talent donation activities. Based on the result of the AHP analysis and survey, this study presents core policy, strategic choice policy, and basic policy for the welfare of local communities. Key Words : Soldier, community welfare, social contribution activity, AHP method *,, hsmin77@ggwf.or.kr **,, jiheewoo@ggwf.or.kr ***,, gomsense@gmail.com,
국방정책연구제 33 권제 3 호 2017 년가을 ( 통권제 117 호 ) Ⅰ. 서론 1990,,,,. 1990, 2000. ( ), 1) (pro bono).,..... 2000, 2010. 1) pro bono public (public interest),,,,. 172
군장병의사회복지분야공헌활성화방안에대한탐색적연구,. 2)...,..,. AHP.. (Military Social Responsibility - MSR)., (economic value estimation). (Analytic Hierarchy Process),.,. 2),. 173
국방정책연구제 33 권제 3 호 2017 년가을 ( 통권제 117 호 ) Ⅱ. 이론적논의및기존연구검토 1. 군장병의사회공헌그리고군의사회적책임 ( )..,. (2013). 3) (, 2013, p. 3)..,, 7 4) (philanthropic responsibility). ( 2016;, 2013)... 3),,., 2,. 4) 7 Carroll(1991) (corporate social responsibility - CSR) Carroll,,,. 174
군장병의사회복지분야공헌활성화방안에대한탐색적연구,..,,,,,. :. (2013). p. 4. < 그림 1> 국민에대한군의책임 175
국방정책연구제 33 권제 3 호 2017 년가을 ( 통권제 117 호 ) 2. 국 내외군장병의사회공헌및재능기부현황분석,,,,.. 5) 124. (,,, ),,,. < 표 1> 군의우수지역사회봉사활동현황분석, (, ) 1:1 1.9% 15 1.3% 17 2.4% 12 (,, ) 4.3% 8 0.0% 28 0.0% 28 4.6% 7 0.3% 25 0.3% 25 (, ) 1.3% 17 (, ) 3.2% 10, 8.3% 5 2.4% 12 0.8% 21 1.9% 15 5) 3 (2014 11-2016 11 ) 372. 176
군장병의사회복지분야공헌활성화방안에대한탐색적연구 < 표 1> 계속.,, 0.5% 22 (, ) (,,, ) 3.2% 10 1.3% 17 0.0% 28 5.4% 6 0.0% 28 0.3% 25 2.4% 12 0.0% 28 0.0% 28 0.0% 28 0.5% 22 0.5% 22 1:1 0.0% 28 (, ) 8.6% 4 PT ( ) 0.0% 28 0.0% 28 0.0% 28, 1.3% 17 ( ) 0.0% 28 0.0% 28,, 15.3% 1 3.8% 9 (,) : : (http://www.mnd.go.kr/), 12.6% 2 (,,, ) 11.3% 3 177
국방정책연구제 33 권제 3 호 2017 년가을 ( 통권제 117 호 ) (Army Community Service - ACS). 6) 10,000 500,000.,,, /, /,, < 2>. < 표 2> 미육군장병들의자원봉사및재능기부활동분류, () () : www.myarmyonesource.com Volunteer Opportunities (Army Volunteer Corps - AVC) (Volunteer Management Information System - VMIS). 7) 6) (ACS Center). 7) (Army Community Service - ACS),,,. 178
군장병의사회복지분야공헌활성화방안에대한탐색적연구. VMIS,,,,.. :. (2016). p. 22. < 그림 2> 군장병들의자원봉사및재능기부참여절차 3. 군장병의사회공헌및재능기부의경제적가치 ( ), /.,.. 179
국방정책연구제 33 권제 3 호 2017 년가을 ( 통권제 117 호 ) (output approach) (input approach) (, 2011)., ( ). 8) (opportunity cost method). (,, ),,. 20 1,200 6%,,. 9). TEV: TWm: WD: t: : / : < 그림 3> 군장병의사회공헌및재능기부활동에대한경제적추정 8) (),. 9) 2015 20-24 187.8 22 1 84,595. 180
군장병의사회복지분야공헌활성화방안에대한탐색적연구 < 표 3> 군장병의사회공헌및재능기부활동의경제적가치 1) ( ) 2) ( ) 32,705 625,000 5.23% 5,201,332,486 20 932,335 6,699,048 13.92% 13,833,732,657 8,145,161 51,529,338 15.81% 15,711,787,262 1: (2016), 2015 2: globalfirepower.com, GFP (2015 );, (2015 ) 52 157. 5.23% 10), 52, 11) (15.81%), 157.1. Ⅲ. 연구설계 (AHP) () (). AHP 1:1, (, 2013). AHP ( ) 10),. 11),, 1 8, 2. 181
국방정책연구제 33 권제 3 호 2017 년가을 ( 통권제 117 호 ).. - -, AHP. 12) 1. 연구대상의선정 23 AHP. 23 7, 14, 3. 0 226. 13) 2. 분석방법의설문구조 (AHP 분석과설문조사 ) AHP. (2012) ⅰ), ⅱ), 12) Saaty(1980) AHP. AHP,. 13) 2016 10,. 182
군장병의사회복지분야공헌활성화방안에대한탐색적연구 ⅲ), ⅳ) 4, (2016) ⅰ), ⅱ), ⅲ), ⅳ), ⅴ) 5. (2016) ⅰ), ⅱ), ⅲ), ⅳ), ⅴ), ⅵ). ⅰ), ⅱ), ⅲ)/, ⅳ)/, ⅴ)/, ⅵ). < 4> AHP,.,, 6,,,,, 18. 5, 1=, 3=, 5=, 2 4 1 3, 3 5. < 표 4> 포천의복지수요파악을위한정책수단 14), (, ) 1:1,, (,, ),,,, 14) - -. 183
국방정책연구제 33 권제 3 호 2017 년가을 ( 통권제 117 호 ) < 표 4> 계속. (, ) (, ) PT (, ),,,,,,,,, 1:1 ( ) (,, ),,, ( ),,,, Ⅳ. 분석결과및논의 1. 지역사회복지수요 AHP 결과분석 AHP,. < 5>. 184
군장병의사회복지분야공헌활성화방안에대한탐색적연구.,. < 표 5> AHP 설문조사대분류결과 0.192 3 0.157 4 0.137 5 0.210 2 0.089 6 0.214 1 1.000 AHP ( 0.214) ( 0.210). ( 0.089). < 6>.. 15). AHP.., 15) 0.65, 0.65 0.192 0.125. 185
국방정책연구제 33 권제 3 호 2017 년가을 ( 통권제 117 호 ), PT. < 표 6> 지역사회복지수요 AHP 분석결과 0.192 0.157 0.137 0.210 0.089 0.214 0.26 0.050 8, 0.09 0.017 17 (, ) 0.65 0.125 2 0.26 0.041 11 0.17 0.027 14 0.57 0.089 4 0.04 0.005 18 (, ) 0.39 0.053 7 0.57 0.078 5 0.52 0.109 3 0.17 0.036 12 0.30 0.063 6 PT 0.24 0.021 16 0.48 0.043 10 0.29 0.026 15 0.22 0.047 9 0.13 0.028 13 (, ) 0.65 0.139 1 2. 군장병의사회공헌및재능기부희망분야조사결과분석 0 226, < 7>. 186
군장병의사회복지분야공헌활성화방안에대한탐색적연구,. < 표 7> 군장병의사회공헌및재능기부희망분야조사결과분석 45 1, 27 2 (, ) 15 7 3 14 8 9 9 8 4 12 (, ) 20 3 17 4 1 16 1 16 3 14 PT 5 11 6 10 1 16 16 5 4 12 (, ) 16 5 25 226, 1:1,,,,,, (, ).,,,. 187
국방정책연구제 33 권제 3 호 2017 년가을 ( 통권제 117 호 ) 3. 정책수단간우선순위결정 AHP,.,,,,. ( - ), ( - ) ( - ),. AHP,,,. AHP.,,.,,. 16) 16).,. 3. 188
군장병의사회복지분야공헌활성화방안에대한탐색적연구... < 표 8> 지역복지서비스정책수단에대한순위종합분석 ( ) ( ) 8 1 4 2, 17 2 8 9 2 7 6 4 11 14 10 13 14 9 3 8 4 8 7 6 18 12 15 18 (, ) 7 3 12 7 5 4 5 3 3 16 11 10 12 16 16 17 6 14 14 11 PT 16 11 16 15 10 10 16 14 15 16 12 15 9 5 1 4 13 12 9 11 1 5 2 1 -., (feasibility) 189
국방정책연구제 33 권제 3 호 2017 년가을 ( 통권제 117 호 ). -, - ()., -, -, -.,. (). -, -, -. Ⅴ. 결론 1. 연구의요약., - -. -, -, -, -, -. -, -, -. 190
군장병의사회복지분야공헌활성화방안에대한탐색적연구. 2. 정책적제언,. (intermediary organization), (Anthony and Austin, 2008;, 2011).,,,,,,, /(, 2000;, 2012),., (, 2016).,. (2011),,,,.,. 191
국방정책연구제 33 권제 3 호 2017 년가을 ( 통권제 117 호 ),,,., (MSR).. 2014~2030.,... ( - AVC) (VMIS).. (social acknowledgement), (, 2005). 20,, () 192
군장병의사회복지분야공헌활성화방안에대한탐색적연구. 17) (volunteer management system - VMS).. 3. 연구의한계및향후연구과제 AHP,.,. 17) VMS ( : www.vms.or.kr). - - - [,,, ( ) ] - VMS(1365 ) 200(), 500(), 1,000(), 2,000 (2), 3,000(3) 5,000(4) - (,,,,, ) -,, - : VMS ( ) 50% : 50 200 30% : 100 : JC 65% (, 1 ) 193
국방정책연구제 33 권제 3 호 2017 년가을 ( 통권제 117 호 ) (external validity or generablizability). (cross-sectional).,,. 논문접수 : 2017 3 23 논문수정 : 2017 10 4 게재확정 : 2017 10 11 참고문헌. (2011). :. :.. (2000). -... (2011). : 1 1., 14(2), pp. 211-224.. (2016).. :.. (2006).., 5(1), pp. 101-135.. (2016).., 28(2). pp. 473-488.. (2011).., 11(3). pp. 81-107. (2012).. 194
군장병의사회복지분야공헌활성화방안에대한탐색적연구 :.. (2016).. :.. (2012).... (2013). : AHP., 51(2). pp. 95-119 (2013)... Anthony, E. K., & Austin, M. J. (2008). The role of an intermediary organization in promoting research in schools of social work: The case of the Bay Area Social Services Consortium. Social Work Research, 32(4). pp. 287-293. Carroll, A. B. (1991). The pyramid of corporate social responsibility: Toward the moral management of organizational stakeholders. Business Horizons. pp. 39-48. 195