CR 200 1-18
CR 200 1-18 :
.,.,...,.... 2001
.,, /,.. 1972 1995 4 1987 1997. 1979, 1987, 1996 1976 1987..,,.,...,,.,, ( ). - iii -
,.. 1970.,,..,,.,. 1970, 1990. 1996.,.,.,... ( ),..,.,. - iv -
.. - v -
. 1. 2 1. 2 2. 2 3. 3. 4 1. 4 2. 5 3. 6. 9 1. 9 2. 14 V. : 17 1. 17 2. 22 I. 2 1 - v i -
1. 21 2. 24....24....26 V II. : 30 34 - v ii -
I......, (, 1994:114-115)..?..???,?,.,,,,. ( ) (Eley & S uny, 1996: Balibar, 1996).... - 1 -
..,. II. 1.,?,?, / /,? 2. 1972 1995 4 1987 1997. 1979, 1987, 1996 1976 1987.. - 2 -
..... 4 4.. 1970, 1980, 1990. 1970. 1980. 1990.. 1970 4 1, 1980 1990. 3. (text analy sis).,,, /, /, - 3 -
,. III. 1. (n atio n ) nation natio.. (ethnos), (race), (state).,,,., (, 1999: 33). (nationalism ),,. 1) 2. (n ation ali s m ),,,,,,, (, 1999). 1 (1999:192),. - 4 -
,,..,.. 1960,,..,.,, (, 1999: 16).....,,,, (S chlesinger, 1987).... (H all, 1996)..,.,,. ( ). - 5 -
., / (Anthia s & Yuval- Davis, 1989)...,. /, /, / /... - (Althu sser, 1971; Bern stein, 1975; William s, 1977; F oucault, 1979; Apple, 1993: McClintock, 1996). 3.,. (1997) (2000), (, 2001). (, 1997;, 2000; &, 2001;, 1993;, 1993, 1995;, 1993;, 1996;, 1996;, 1997;, 1998)..,, - 6 -
..,... 1970, 1980, 1990.. 2). (gender - blinded).,.,,. III, IV V. IV. 2 (1993), (1997), (2000), (2001). - 7 -
1...,.,... /,,,,,,,.,,,, /.,., (, 1994: 123). 3).,,.,, (, 1992),,.. 3 (, 1992). - 8 -
?..,...,. :,,.,,, (1979 :36). <,,,. >... <?> <! >(, 1995: 36-38).,..,.., - 9 -
.. :,?...,,,,,....,,..., (, 1979:93).,....?(, 1987: 137-138)., (, 1996:81).,., (,, ), (Callahan, 1999).. (Balibar, 1996).. - 10 -
. 1990. 1996, (pp. 30-32). 1970 1990..,, (, 1996:33)...,.. ( ),..,,,,.. : (, 1987: 12).. - 11 -
( 1997 : 68).,..,.,.. 60. 60,,,.. 70 (, 1999)... 1969 12 5 4 20.,,.. (, 1999: 130).. - 12 -
.,,,,,. 4)..,,....?., (McClintock, 1996).,.... ( ) 4 (2000:92-96). - 13 -
. ( ). ( )...... 5) 2.,....., (Malkki, 1996). :,,,! 5,. (, 1991: 36)., 2 ( ) (1972,, 125-131). - 14 -
...(1979,, pp.131-132).,..,., (1979,, 60-62).. ' (, 1997:76).?!,...., (, 1972: 60-61)..... ( 1997 )..,,,..,,,.,..,. - 15 -
, (Malkki, 1996)., :,..... (1987: 125-127).......... (, 1979:129).........,... (, 1995: 16-19).,.,., (aborescent ) - 16 -
(Malkki, 1996:437).... (, ),,, (, 2001: 546-551).. V. : 1..,,.,., 1979,,,. 1979, - 17 -
. 1987, 6.25, 1997,.. 1979..,,.,.,,., (, 1997;, 1999).,..,... 1969 " "....,. - 18 -
..., (, 2001)..,,.,, :...,.,. 10.,.,, (1979 : 84)., 1979,.,... 10 (, 1999). - 19 -
. 1970,.,,,. 2.. 1987, 1995, 1997., 1972.6)., (Mclintock : 269).., 1997... 7). 6.. 7. - 20 -
..,. 1961, 3,. 7.,..,,,.,,,, (, 1991)..,... (Yuval Davis, 1996). V I. 1.,. - 2 1 -
:..,..,.......... 6 25.,..,.,.............,. (. 1979:28-31).....,,.,.,...,..., (1987: 97-99).,,....... ( 1972: 49-53). - 22 -
....?! (, 1987: 85).,.,.. (, 2001: 569-570). 1990..8), 1979 23, 6 (26%). 1987, 12 2 (16.7%), 1 (8.3%). 1996 9, 1 (11.1%). 87. 96,,.. 1972, 45 4 (8.9%) 8.. - 23 -
(91.1%),. 1995. 30 18 (60.0%),, 12 (40% ). 1987 1997., 6-7%.. 1987, 1997 < 45 >. 1987, 97. 1990. 1996.. 2. : ( )., 3.,., (Chatterjee, 1993)... - 24 -
.. 1979,., 1962. 1971.,,, (, 1997: 143-152;, 1999: 96-107). :..,....,,. (1979, 125-127)..,,.,., - 25 -
(, 1999). 1970 1980, / :,,...,,..,,., (, 1987:93)., (, 1997: 200)...9)... 9 1996, 1979 1987 1996. - 26 -
...,,,,,,. 1972 1990., :,,. <, 1972: 60-61)..,. : 1866....... 16-27 -
... 1950 6 25 (, 1972: 179)...... (, 1972)., (, 1995: 85).,,.,.,,. (, 1999:, 2001). 90,,.,.... - 28 -
:..........,! >....,?...,?!,!..............?!..?...................! 1... - 29 -
(, 1987: 90-93).!... ( ) ( ) ( )..,. 10).,....,. 11) Cynthia Enloe,,.. (McClintock, 1997 ). 10 (2001). 1960 < >. 11.. - 30 -
V II. :.,, /,..,,.,....,,.,, ( ).,.,. 1970.,, - 3 1 -
..,.,. 1970, 1990. 1996.,.,.,... ( ),..,.,.?? - 32 -
..,,,.?....,... - 33 -
< > 1979.. 4-1.. 1987.. 4-1.. 1996.. 4-1.. < > 1972.. 4.. 1987.. 4.. 1995.. 4.. 1997.. 4.. < > (2001). :.. 9 (2). pp. 173-209. (2001)., : 1960,,. ( )... (1999)... (1998).,,. 12(1). pp. 87-118. (1999). :.. (1992).... pp 16-25. (1996). :. :. & (2001)... (2001).. ( ). -.. (1991)... - 34 -
(1999).?. ( ).. :. (1996)... (1993). -.. (2001). :.. 21 (2 ). (1994).... pp 114-137. (1993)... 26. 185-202. (1997).. ( )... (1997). :.. (1996)... (1993).. 10. 63-86. (2001). :., 21 (2 ). (1997)... (1993). I I.. (1999).. ( ).. (1997)... (2000). :.. Althu sser, L.(1971). L en in and P hilos op hy and O ther E ssays.(t ran s) B. Brew ster, London : New Left Books. Anthias, F. & N. Yuval- Davis (1996). W oman - nation - state. in Geoff Eley and Ronald Grig or S uny (ed s). B ecom ing N a tional: A R ead er. N ew - 35 -
York and Oxford: Oxford Univer sity Press. Balibar, E. (1996). "T he Nation F orm : H istory and Ideology ", in Geoff Eley and Ronald Grig or S uny (ed s). B ecom ing N a tional: A R ead er. N ew York and Oxford: Oxford Univer sity Press. Apple, M. W. (1993). Official K nowledge. New York : Routledge. Bernstein, B. (1977). Class, Cod es and Control. vol 3. London : Routledge & K egan Paul. Callahan, C. (1999). "Nationalism and Ethnicity ", J. H utchin son& A. Smith (ed s). N a tionalism : Critical Concep ts in P olitical S cience. London and Yew York : Routledge. Foucault, M. (1977). D iscip line and P unish. H armonw orth : Penguin. Hall, S. (1988). T he Road in the Garden :'T hatcherism A mong the T heorists.' In C. Nelson and L. Grossberg (eds ). M arx ism and the I n terp retation of Culture. U rbana: Univer sity of Illinois Press. Eley G. & R. G. Suny. (1996). "Introduction : From the Moment of Social H istory to the Work of Cultural Representation ", in Geoff Eley and Ronald Grigor Suny (eds ) B ecom ing N a tional: A R ead er. N ew York and Oxford: Oxford University Press. Hall, S. (1996). T he Question of Cultural Identity. in S. Hall et al (eds). M od ernity and I ts F utures. Cambridge: P olity. Kandiyoti, D.(1991). Identity and Its Discontents: W omen and the N ation. M illenn ium J ournal of I n terna tional S tud ies. 20. 3. 429-43. Lee, Y. (1997). M odern E d uca tion, T ex tb ooks, and the I m ag e of the N a tion: P olitics of M od ern iza tion and N a tionalism in K orean E d uca tion, 1880-1910. Ph. D. Dissertation, The U niver sity of Wiscon sin - Madison. Malkki, L. (1996). "N ational Geographic: T he Rooting of P eoples and the T errotorization of N ational Identity among S cholars and Refugees", in Geoff Eley and Ronald Grigor S uny (eds) B ecom ing N ational: A R ead er. New York and Oxford: Oxford Univer sity Press. Mclintock, A.(1996). "No Longer in a Future H eaven: Nationalism, Gender, and Race", in Geoff Eley and Ronald Grigor S uny (ed s) B ecom ing N a tional: A R ead er. New York and Oxford : Oxford University Pre ss. - 36 -
Schlesing er, P. (1987). On N ational Identity : Some Conception s and Misconception s Criticized. S ocial S cience I nf orm a tion. 26. 2. William s, R.(1977). M arx ism A nd L itera ture. N ew York : Oxford Univ ersity Press. - 37 -
- 38 -