한국인터넷문화의특성과발전방안연구 정책연구 09-68 인터넷참여문화선진화를위한제도적지원방안 2009. 12.

1.,....,.,,.,,

2,,,.,. 2009 12

3 1 9 1 19 1 19 1. 19 2. 20 2 22 1 22 1. 22 2. 25 2 27 1. 27 2. 31 3. 33 3 34 3 36 1 36 2 41 1. 41 2. 48 3. 52

4 4. 58 5. 61 3 63 4 66 1 66 1. 66 2. 74 2 77 1. 77 2. : BBC Have Your Say 81 3 82 1. 82 2. : e-democracy project 88 4 91 1. 91 2. 97 3. : 99 5 106 1. 106 2. 108 6 114 5 117 1 117 2 119 123

5 2 1 24 2 2 3 25 2 3 26 2 4 30 2 5 32 3 1 37 3 2 39 3 3 41 3 4 43 3 5 49 3 6 56 3 7 58 3 8 65 4 1 66 4 2 68 4 3 69 4 4 75 4 5 : 83 4 6 : (Bric) 84 4 7 : 86 4 8 : e-democracy project 87

6 4 9 2.0 98 4 10 105 4 11 105 4 12 116

7 2 1 27 3 1 36 3 2 (2002~2008) 38 3 3 46 3 4 47 3 5 48 3 6 50 3 7 50 3 8 52 3 9 53 3 10 54 3 11 55 3 12 59 3 13 59 3 14 / 60 3 15 62 3 16 63 4 1 77 4 2 (BRIC) 85 4 3 ParticipationNZ Wiki 86 4 4 e- 89

8 4 5 e-democracy 90 4 6 91 4 7 94 4 8 2.0 99 4 9 101 4 10 103 4 11 e-democracy.org 110 4 12 111 4 13 e-representative 112 4 14 113 4 15 BBC Democracy Live 114

9 1-1..,.,,. (, ),, 3,. 2,. 3.,. 4,

10. 2-1,, -, Meijer (2009) (, ),, 3. Meijer,,,.. - 2 Jenkins(2006),,.,.,,.,.

11. Rheingold(2003), Benkler(2006). Keen(2006),,,, Lanier(2006). 3-1 1994,,,, TV,., 2002 16,,. - 2,. 6 98.5%, 28.8%(, 2009), 87.9%(KADO, 2008).

12, 5%, 0.12% 30.5%. 14.3%, 5% 44.2% (, 2009)... 2008, 2005.., 2002, 2.0 9.7% (KISDI, 2008).,.. 2002, 2007,...,,,,

13.,., 180cm,. 4-1., (co-regulation) (co-management).,, 3 ADR(Alternative Dispute Resolution) FCC. - 2,.

14,,.,..,.. - 3. e-editor. e-democracy. e-democracy, 1,500., (e-editor) - 4 2.0

15. 2.0.,,,, 4 2.0., - -. <,,, >, 2006 2009 2 20,424 79. - 5,.,.., (Minnesota E-democracy), (Smart Vote) (My Vote), BBC Democracy Live.

16 5., (given) (selective).,..,., (discipline)..,..,...,

17,.,.,..,,..,..,,,,.,,.,.

1 19 1 1 1... 2.0.,,,,.,,, (prosumer) (produser) (networked individuals). ( ).

20,.,. ( ) ( ).. 2...,, -,,. (social participation), (policy participation),

1 21 (political participation),.,. ( )/,, (internet civic culture). (,, )..

22 2 1 1., (, 2007).. Jenkins(2006),,,. 2.0,,,,,,. (Rheingold, 2002),, (smart mob),. (net generation)

2 23 (Tapscott, 2008). (Benkler, 2006),..,. (Keen, 2006),,,.,. 1989 (virtual reality) (Lanier, 2006). (digital maoism),. 1) 1) (Jenkins, 2006),,.

24 2 1,, / (Jenkins, 2006) (Rheingold, 2002) (Benkler, 2006) (Tapscott, 2006),,, / (Kean, 2006) (Lanier, 2006),, (Jenkins, 2006),,.., (cybernetics).. (, 2000)., (, 2009)..

2 25,, (, 2001).,,,,,. 2 2,, 3 (, 2009). 2 2 3, IT 2.,,., OECD(2003) (2006), Meijer (2009). OECD(2003),,,, (2006).

26 2 3 -,,, (e-petition) Meijer (2009),,, 3,.,,.,.. Meijer (2009).,.

2 27 2 1 2,.,,,. 1..,,,, (Cornnery, 1997; Dahlberg, 1998,, 1999).,,,

28, (, 2000;, 2000).. (2005) 17, (2005a,b,c, 2006),,,,.,,., (2009).,,,.,.. (Levy, 1994),,,.

2 29,. (Surowiecki, 2004) (wisdom of crowd)..,,,, 4.,,.,,..,...,.,., (2007) 2.0, 2.0 (participation), (sharing),

30 (being open).,,., 2 4. 2 4 (Levy, 1994) (Bloom, 1995) (Surowiecki, 2004) & (D.Tapscott & A.Williams, 2006) & (Negri&Hardt, 2008) (Bruns, 2008) (Shircky, 2008) (Jenkins, 2006),,, IQ.,,,, 4 (Produsage). -,. ( ),

2 31 2.,., Meijer (2009),.,,,,. (2001). OECD(2003) (consultation) (active participation)...,. -.,,. OECD,,,, 5.,

32,,,,,,,,. (2004),,, 4.,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, DB,,,,,. 2 5 OECD (2001) (2004) /,,,,,,,,,,,,,, -,,,,,, DB,,,,,

2 33, (2009) - 2.0-.. 2.0. 3..,., (2006),, (2005),,., (2005), (2005),.,

34 (, 2000;, 2000, 2001, 2004;, 2001;, 2003;, 2005;, 2008).,,,..., 20 (, 2004). 3.,.,,.

2 35,..,,,,..

36 3 1 1994,. 1999 1000 2008 6 3519, 77% (, 2008).,,, TV,. 3 1

3 37 2002 2005, 2006. 3 1 / 1994~2001 2002~2004 2005~2007 2008 (1994) (1999) (2000) 16, / (2000) 57.3% (2004) 3 (2002),, 16 (2004) 17, (2002) (2002) (2003) (2005), (2007) 17 (2005) (2006) (2008) 7, (2008) 18 :,, (2009) (2004) ( ) (2008) (2006) 2.0 (UCC ). 2000 16. 57.3%. 2002 16,,. 2004, 2005

38, 2008. 2008.., (2003 ),, 2006 UCC.. 3-2. 3 2 (2002~2008) * (2009).,

3 39,. (digital generation), 2000. 2000. 2.0 1.. (2008) 2000 2005,. 3 2 2000 2002 SOFA 2004 (5.24 ) (11.27) (1.7 25:54) 2004 (7.21 23:22) 3 PC ( ) (5.25 11:40) (11.28) (1.7 15:00) (7.22) TV(5.25) TV(11.30) KBS(1.13) (1.13) 3 15, 10 (11.30) (12.14) 11 5

40 2005 2005 X 2005 2005 2005 2005 (1.8) (1.17) (5.1) (6.5 23:00) (12.5) : (2008),, P2P,,,,,, ( ) (1.10) (1.18) (5.6) (6.6 11:00) YTN (6.24 09:43) (12.5) (1.10), TV(1.19) (1.18), TV(1.19) TV(5.6) TV(6.7) YTN (6.24 09:41), TV (6.24 ) TV(12.5) 4,000 (1.14) (5.6) CCTV 10 (6.11) (6.28).,,,,,. (2008).

3 41 3 3,,. 2,,. 2 1..

42. 2008 6 98.5% (, 2008), 87.9% (KADO, 2008).. 2006 5 2007 4 1 3412,,,, 8 93.76%, 70%. 2008 95.4% 92.5%.. 6 92.8% 1, 74.3% 1, (70.7%) (70.2%). ( 2009).,,...,.

3 43.,,. 2006 84.8%. (46.0%) (32.9%) (12.1%). 45.6%, 53.8%. 2.5, (52.4%), (21.9%), (11.8%) ( 2006). 3 4 1 54.2 46.0 2 21.9 32.9 3 11.8 12.1 4 8.6 8.9 5 3.3 0.2 6 0.2 : 2006,.., ( 2005).

44.,.(Ong 2002; 2009 ).,,,.,, ( 2005)., /,..,,,.. (, 2009)..

3 45.,. 0.12% 30% (, 2009). 14.3%. 5% 44.2%. 65.3%, 36.5%. 5% 30.5%, 2.5%, 0.12% 3 1 (, 2008)....,., (, 2009)..,

46., (, 2005). 2009, 2,661, 3,337 1/4, 1/5 648... Sunstein(2009).. 3 3 ( : %) :, (2009)

3 47. :.,.,. 3 4,,, NGO,,,,.,,, 24.

48,. 3 5,,.,... 2..,,.

3 49,,,.. 2008,. 3 5 F. 4 2008 30 2 Essjay. Shirky(2008) 20 80. (Wales) 2% 73.4%, Swartz(2006).

50 2006 11 30,,,,,,,,, 10 Ortega (2007) 10 10% 90%, Swartz(2006) 2% 73.4%,. 3 6 : Ortega (2007) 3 7 : Ortega (2007)

3 51,,,..,. 2008. 2008 4 ~6, 6 7626 10% 71% 10 2 1810 27.6 (, 2008).. (, 2009). 2005. (2007),.,.

52 3. 2002..,.,,., 2004 12 2005 7,,,,,, 7,,,,,,,,. 3 8

3 53 2005 11 7 1 49,,.,,.,, 2008. 2007,.,.,. 3 9

54, 2005 1 6 2008 5 8 (, 2009). 3 10, 41.1% (36.5%), (18.6%), (13.3%) (, 2009). ( 2.0 ) 35.2%, 2.0 9.7% (KISDI, 2008).,

3 55. 3 11.,,.,.,,, 4.,,. 3 6.

56 3 6,? O/X 1,2,3 ( :1 : 2 :3)? O/X? O/X? O/X? O/X? O/X,? O/X 1,2,3 ( :1 : 2 :3)? O/X? O/X? O/X? O/X? O/X, O/X?,? O/X 1,2,3 ( :1 : 2 :3)? O/X? O/X :1 : 2 :3 1,2,3 /? O/X? O/X? O/X /? O/X

3 57.,.,.,,,,,.,,.., 0.88,,, 0.84.,,, 0.86. 0.93,,. 0.96..,,..

58 3 7 0.84 0.68 0.63 0.96 0.78 0.02 0.05 0.63 0.58 0.32 0.84 0.86 0.02 0.96 0.67 0.05 0.86 0.02 0.58 0.38 0.65 0.86 0.44 0.58 0.63 0.84 0.11 0.93 0.09 0.49 0.65 0.11 0.44 0 0.3 0.42 0.64 0.63 0.58 0.57 0.88 0.11 0.29 0.58 0.46 0.38 0.86 0.79 0.09 0.53 0 0.24 0.58 0.58 0.35 0.23 0.24 0.3 0.58 0.34 0.84 0.64 0.79 0.58 0.71 0.65 0.64 0.79 0.58 0.67 0.26 0.45 0.38 0.09 0.3 0.24 0.88 0.79 0.09 0.5 4. 2002,,. 2000 16 8.7%, 2002 16 14.2% 2004 17 54% (, 2000;, 2005;, 2009), 2002 16 2.9% 2007 17 9% 3 (, 2007).

3 59 3 12 3 13, 2007,. 16 17.,,.

60 3 14 / 2.0,..,,,. 2008,,,.

3 61 5.., X,,.,. (2009).,.,., UCC,,., ( )...,.,.,..

62 3 15 : (2009). 180cm TV,., (daum ),..

3 63 3 16 3 1994,,, TV..,,., 5% 30.5% 14.3%.,.

64. 2008 2005.,., 2002 2.0 9.7% (KISDI, 2008).,. 2002 2007,,,,. 2008,,,.

3 65 3 8 - : 98.5%, 87.9% -, : 0.12%, 5% 30.5%, 14.3% - : - ( : ) - : 2008 4 ~6, 6 7626 10% 71% 10 2 1810 27.6 - ( : ) - : 41.1% (2007.12 ), (36.5%), (18.6%) (13.1%) -, - 2007 -

66 4 1 1.., (KADO, 2009).,,.,,. (, 2009)., 4 1. 4 1 : (2009),,,

4 67..,,.,,...,,,, (, 1999).,.,. ( 1999; 2006)....

68. 2006 12 2007 7, 10, UCC 30, 20.,,,. 2008 10 10. 4 2 44 5( ) ( ). 2. 10 22 3( ) 44 5 1 2. 1. 3 (, ) 30 2. 3 ( 2 1 ) 20 3. 3 ( ) 30

4 69.,. 2008, 2008 10. 4 3 2008. 12. 24 2008. 11. 3 2008. 10. 30 70 ( ) 2 1. 1 3. 311 2( ) 311 3 1. 307, 309, 309 2, 309 3 311 2...

70.,.,.,.,.,..... ( 2008; 2008).. 2) 2 2 2) : 6878. 2007. 6. 18.

4 71 5, 2 1.,. 3),,. 4),.. 5)., 50%,. 3) : 7107. 2007. 6. 18 4) : 174505. 2006. 6. 19. 5) 7108. 2007. 7. 19.

72,. 2008. 6) ( ). 7) 2 1.,. 6),,.. 7) : 174595. 2006. 7. 7

4 73 10. 11. ( ) (, ). 2009 1 13, 6..,.. 2008.,.

74.. NHN,, SK,..,., (KADO, 2009). 2. (2008)., 2.0,.,. (2009),,. (, 2009).

4 75 4 4 -, FCC ICRA IAJapan Ofcom IWF CSA( ) (KJM) (DLM) (MDA) (SBA) (AFA) (AUI) (FSM),,,,, (PAGi) : (, 2009)., 2008 FDI (national digital council).,,,. 1978,,,, (, 2009).

76, 2002 (IAJapen),,, 2008 (EMA) (, 2009). (ENC), (, 2008). FCC (rulemaking) (adjudication), (reasonable network management)., / ADR (Alternative Dispute Resolution) (, 2008). ADR, 3,. ADR,,,,,.,. (co-regulation) (co-management).

4 77 4 1 : 2009. 10. 09. 2 1. - (architecture)..,.,.,..,.

78..,.,.,.....,.. Ong /. / / (, 2009). /.

4 79,, (, 2009).... Dutton (Dutton, 2007).,, (, 2008). 2006 9,.,,,,, (, 2007).,,., (, 2008).

80,,,.., (information overload) 8).... (moderator) (editor).,. 1) Coleman Gøtze (affirming) (forming),, (online free-for-all)... 8) butler.(butler, 2001)

4 81,.,,.,., 9).,. (Coleman & Gøtze, 2001)..,,.. (, 2005). 2. : BBC Have Your Say BBC Have Your Say. Have Your Say,. Have Your Say About Have Your Say,. BBC Have Your Say, 9) Coleman Gøtze.

82 24.. Your Pictures & Stories,.,. BBC Have Your Say. BBC WHYS(World s Have Your Say).,.... Have Your Say. 3 1..

4 83 3,,...,.,.,.. 4 5 : (http://agora.media.daum.net/) 2009 13 2 8, / / / / /MY, / 08 ( )

84..,,.,.. (Bric). 4 6 : (Bric) (Bric) (http://bric.postech.ac.kr/) Sci. 9 7 63.,,,

4 85 4 2 (BRIC)

86 4 7 : ParticipationNZ Wiki (http://wiki.participation.e.govt.nz/wiki/) 2006 (,, ), 4 3 ParticipationNZ Wiki

4 87. e-editor., e-editor, / e-editor. e-democracy. e-democracy, 1,500., (e-editor). 4 8 : e-democracy project e-democracy project : 2, (e-editor) - 1,500

88. e-democracy project. 2. : e-democracy project., ICTs ICTs,., 1 (e-democracy conference room).,,..,,,.,. ICTs.,. (Murabayashi, 2006). 2 e- e-.

4 89 4 4 e- : http://www.e-kocho.pref.mie.jp/comment/., (e-editor). (coordinator)...., e-....,.

90.. (needs)., ( )...... 4 5 e-democracy.,. 5., 1,,. 2 e-editor, 3 (pilot)

4 91. 4 e-, 5. ( ). 4 6 4 1.. 1). 20,, (, 2000).

92 (, 2004). (governance) (Governance). governance, Governance (, 2005). (governance) (Governance)..,... 20, (Governance)., e- (citizen-centered e-governance) (post-governance) (, 2007).,.

4 93,. (e-participation system) e-..,,.., (deliberation).., e- e-. 2).

94.,,,,...,,,..,.,,.. 4-7. 4 7

4 95.....,.....,. (agent system),

96.,...,, (, 2000).,...,. NGO, ( 2000).

4 97.,,, (, 2007). 2. 2.0 2.0, /., 2.0. 2.0 (twitter) (tweets) 140,,. (facebook)...,. (MySpace)..

98. (Youtube),,,., 2.0. 4 9 2.0 2.0 / - - - - - - - -, /,,,. ( / / ).,.,,. ( / ) 2.0 ( ). 2.0 SNS, 2.0.

4 99 4 8 2.0 3. : e-,,,. e-.. (, 2002).,.,

100. 2006..,.,.,.,..,,. e-.,,,,,

4 101.,., (, 2007) 4 9 2007 6,,,, WOW.. 1,..,

102., WOW,,,,. 10).,,.,,,,...,,.,,,,..,,,,,,,. 10).

4 103,..,... 1),., 4.,. 4 10 - : - :, - :,,, :

104,,,.,.,,.,. 2) 11),. 2004 2008 3 1 12), e-.,,. 11) 2007 (Government Technology Awards 07) (2007 10 ) ; 2007 (2007 12 ). 12) 100 1. 100 26. 2004, 2006 1, 3 1. 2007,,,,,,,, 10. 3,,, 1. 2003 73.48 2005 81.70, 2007 87.74.(, 2008 6 27.)

4 105 4 10 06.10.10~ 09.1.31 20,424 17,459 1,668 263 114 79 :. 2006 10 2009 1 20,424 ( 4 10 ). 730, 24. 4,600 2009 4 400. 114 79. 4 11 17,459 1,668 114 79 1 2006. 11. 21 1,051 106 9 8 2 2006. 12. 22 896 148 8 4 3 2007. 2. 22 1,625 145 9 8 4 2007. 4. 26 1,221 76 9 9 5 2007. 6. 28 848 60 7 3 6 2007. 9. 19 1,239 74 7 4 7 2007. 12. 13 1,637 67 7 4 8 2008. 2. 28 1,003 74 7 4 9 2008. 4. 24 1,250 92 7 4 10 2008. 6. 26 1,076 124 7 4 11 2008. 9. 4 1,083 96 10 7 12 2008. 10. 28 1,677 116 7 5 13 2008. 12. 22 1,344 221 9 7 14 2009. 2. 26 1,509 269 11 8 :.

106 2006 11 2009 2 14, 20,424 114. 1,668 8.2%, 114 0.56%. 79 114 69.2%. 33 (28.9%),,.,..,.,. - -. 5 1.,.

4 107.... /,,., /. /., ( ).,. (deliberation)...,,, (, 2008).,

108 /..,. (e-citizen jury), (e-petition), (e-peoples panel),,,,,, IPTV. 2.. 1) (e-democracy.org) (e-democracy.org). e-democracy.org 1994 Minnesota e-democracy, (issue forum) 2009 50. e-democracy 13) 13) e-democracy.org, ( 1 2 ),,,

4 109 /.,. e-democracy.,,,,...,. e-democracy ( 50-200 ),. e-democracy.org,. e-democracy.org, 14),. e-democracy.org 2.0 (tagging) ( ),,, (netizen-generated content). 14) Consider starting with an area under 6 million in population. This just seems to work better. Neighborhoods are also a natural starting point, but try startingcitywidefirst and encourage others to establish neighborhood e-mail lists or online forums http://e-democracy.org/if

110 (citizen-generated content). 2006 Tagging 2006 2008 Tagging 2008. 4 11 e-democracy.org 2) (Open Congress) (Open Congress, www.opencongress.org) (Participatory Politics Foundation & Sunlight Foundation).,, 2.0 RSS (feed)

4 111. 2.0, RSS RSS. 4 12. 1) e-representative 2006 2 2008 5 e-representative.,,,,

112 5 ( ),,,. 4 13 e-representative 2) Smart Vote / My Vote (civic literacy),..

4 113 4 14 3) BBC, Democracy Live BBC Democracy Live,.,.

114 4 15 BBC Democracy Live : http://news.bbc.co.uk/democracylive/hi 6.,., (co-regulation) (co-management).,,,.,

4 115,..,. e-democracy. e-democracy, 1,500., (e-editor). 2.0. 2.0.,,,, 4 2.0., - -.,,,, 2006 2009 2 20,424 79.,

116.,.., (Minnesota e-democracy), (Smart Vote) (My Vote), BBC Democracy Live. 4 12 - - - - ( : e-democracy project ) - - 2.0 - -

5 117 5 1.. (, ),, 3. 2. 3 1994,.,,. 2002

118, 2007.. 4., (co-regulation) (co-management)..,,,,.,. e-editor.,, 2.0.,,.

5 119. 2 ( ).,,,,..., (given) (selective).,..,.

120, (discipline).... /.... 15)..,..., 15),,,,.

5 121,.,,,..,.,.,..,,.. (e-citizen jury), (e-petition), (e-peoples panel),,,,,, IPTV.

122,..,,,,.,,.,. (professional citizen), (citizen-administrators),. - -.

123 (2007),, 51(1). (2000),, 14(1), pp.7~40 (2008), e-governance : e-, 2008 (3). (2009), :. (2005),,.. (2006), e-,, 11(1), pp.61~82. (2007), e- :, 14 2. (2005), :, 19 3. (2007),, :. (2002), : 16,. (2004),, 16(4). (2000),, :. (2004),, 16 2. (2008),, NIDA

124 1. (2008),, 20 2, pp.407~425. (2004), 17 :, 38 5. (2001), : 16, 17 2. (2000), 16, 34(3). (2006),, 20, pp.85~119. (2006), :, 201 9 3 24, pp.33~79. (2005a),, 39 2. (2005b),,. (2005c),, 27 pp.1~23. (2003), :, 18. (2007),, 10 1, pp.47~68. (2009),, 9 1, pp.5~44. (1997), :, 4 9.

125 (2007),, 19 8 415. (2009), /, 53 1, pp. 109~132. (2009. 1. 15),,, (http://www.donga.com/fbin/archive_dfsrchview?n=d011501457683192), R. (1999), :, :. (2005), : 17, 11 3. (2000),, 44-4. (1998),,. (2007), 2.0, 8 2, pp.15~20. (2008), :, 22 3, pp.1~30. (1999),, 43(4). (2002), Cyber-Governance :, 12 2, pp.109~134. (2005), :,. (2007), 2.0, CEO Information 588. (2005),,,,. (2003), :, : 2003.

126 (2009),,. (2006), e-, 201 9(4), pp. 105-139. (2009), 2.0,. (2000), 16, 16. (2005), IT : e-governance,. (2005),, 13 4. (2008),, 11 3, pp.31~54. (2008), 17,, 42(2). (2003), 16, 37(3)., (2000), 16, 34(3). (2009),,, 12 1, pp.59~84. (2000), :, 14(2), pp.109~150. (2008),, (30), pp.1~25., (2009),,,, 53(2). (2005), :, 17 2, pp.139 172.

127 (2005),,, 49 1, pp.29~56. (2007),,,, 51 1, pp.144~171. (2008), - (Blind), 76. (2000), 21 :,,, 2000. (2008), :17 UCC, 42(2). (2009. 10. 09),,, 2008 (02). (2006), (2008), 2.0 (2001),, 12 3. (2006), :, 33. (2007), e : :. (2008. 6.27) 10 2 1810 (http://news.chosun.com/site/data/html_dir/2008/06/27/2008062700043.html) (2005),,.

128 (2006), e-governance, 13 2, pp.189~205. (2004), :., 10(1), pp.239-261. (2009), (1994), :. (2006), : 2.0 - (2008a), 2008 (2008b), 2008 (2008c), 2008 (2009), 2009. (2001), (2009a), (2009b), (2009c), (2009d), (2008a), 2008 (2008b),, (2006),, 66, pp.8~15. (2009), (2000),, :. (2009),, 76, pp.336-367.

129 (2008), :,, 2008. (2009),, 17(1), pp.102~134. (2001),, 45(3). (2009a), (2009b), 2009. Benkler, Y. (2006). The Wealth of Networks: How Social Production Transforms Markets andfreedom, Yale University Press. Bloom, H. (1995). Global Brain: The Evolution of Mass Mind from the Big Bang to the 21st Century, John Wiley & Sons Inc. Bruns, A. (2008) Blogs, Wikipedia, Second Life, and Beyond: From Production to Produsage, Peter Lang Publishing Inc. Clift, L. (2004). E-government and Democracy: Representation and Citizen Engagement in the Information Age. UNPAN/DESA World Public Sector Report. Coleman & Gøtze (2001). Bowling Together: Online Public Engagement in Policy Deliberation, http://bahamaseducationinow.net/documents/bowlingtogether.pdf Cornnery, B. (1997). IMHO: Authority and Egalitarian Rhetoric in the Virtual Coffeehouse, Internet Culture, pp.161~179. Dahlberg, L. (1998). Cyberspace and the Public Sphere, Convergence4(1), pp.70~84. Dutton, M. (2007). e-democracy: Reconfiguring Participation in Governance and Public Policy, 10 1. Jenkins. H. (2006). Convergence Culture: where old and new media collide, New York:

130 NYU Press. Keen, A. (2006). The cult of the amateur, Doubleday. Keohane, R.K. & Joseph N. (1998). Power and Interdependence in the Information Age., Foreign Affairs, pp.77-95. Lampe (2006) Ratings Use in an Online Discussion System: The Slashdot Case, University of Michigan. Lanier, J. (2006) The Hazards of the New Online Collectivism, An Edge Original Essay. Levy, P.(2002).,,,. Meijer, A., Burger,N. & Ebbers, W. (2009). Citizens2Citizens : Mapping Participatory Practices on the Internet, Electronic Jounal of e-government Vol7 Issue1. Murabayashi M et al. (2006). Activities for e-democracy in Mie Prefecture, RDD 27(2), pp. 104-111. Negri, A. & Hardt, M.,(2008). Commonwealth, Havard University Press. OECD.(2003). Promise and Problems of E-Democracy: Challenges of Online Citizen Engagement. Ong, W. (2002). Orality and Literacy: The Technologizing of the Word, New York: Routledge. Ortega, F., Gonzalez-Barahoma, J.M., Robles, G.(2007). On The Inequality of contributions to Wikipedia Rheingold, H.(2002). Smart Mob, Cambridge, MA : Perseus Publishing. Shirky, C. (2008).,. Sunstein, C. (2009),, :. Surowiecki, J. (2004). The Wisdom of Crowds, Random House Inc. Swartz.A. (2006). Who writes wikipedia [Online] Available:http://www.aaronsw.com/

131 weblog/whowriteswikipedia Tapscott, D. (2008). Wikinomics : How Mass Collaboration Changes Everything, Portfolio.

Northwestern University Northwestern University 2009 12 2009 12 2 38( 1-1) TEL: 570-4114 FAX: 579-4695 6 ( ) ISBN 978-89-8242-662-9 94320 978-89-8242-665-0 ( )