,.,,. (Vocational Ethics) (, 1999), Brown(2012). (, 2004).,,,,, ,400 (,,, 2011;, 2006)., (, 2006; Brown, 2012). (harm) (, 2006). NCDA(National

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download ",.,,. (Vocational Ethics) (, 1999), Brown(2012). (, 2004).,,,,, ,400 (,,, 2011;, 2006)., (, 2006; Brown, 2012). (harm) (, 2006). NCDA(National"

상면 임
6 years ago
Views:

1 담학연구,,. 4 20, 60., 2, 10.., , 15,,,,,,,,,,,,,,..,,,. (Corresponding Author): / / bongwhan@sm.ac.kr

2 ,.,,. (Vocational Ethics) (, 1999), Brown(2012). (, 2004).,,,,, ,400 (,,, 2011;, 2006)., (, 2006; Brown, 2012). (harm) (, 2006). NCDA(National Career Development Association) 11 (NCDA, 2009), (, 2014;, 2010;,, 2011;,, 2014), (,, 2015;,,, 2014;, 2012;,, 2011;, 2012). Bronson(2010), (2015) 21. Kitchener(1984) 5. (Respect for Autonomy), (Nonmaleficence), (Beneficience), (Justice), (Fidelity) APA(American Psychological Association), ACA(American Counseling Association), (, 2014;, 2013). Brown(2012),,

3 ,,,,, 7. Kitchener(1984),. Kitchener(1984), (Sperry, 2007).,, Kitchener(1984),,,., (2006),. Kitchener(1984). ACA, NCDA, IAEVG (International Association for Educational and Vocational Guidance),,,,, 1. (, 2014), (, 2015, ). (Sperry, 2007), (,,, 2009 ).,,..,, (2007) (2005),,,,,,. (2011),,,. (2002), (37.6%), (11.22%), (9.27%), (5.36%),

4 ( ) ACA 1) (1996) NCDA 2) (1997) IAEVG 3) (1995) 4) (2004) 5) (2002) 6) (1979) 7) (2014) (1), (2), (3) (4), (5), (6),, (7) (8),, (9) (1), (2), (3), (4), (5), (6), (7),, (8), (9) (1), (2) (3), (4), (5) (1), (2) (3), (4) (5), (6), (7) (8), (9) (10), (11) (12), (13) (1), (2), (3), (4) (5), (6), (7), (8) (9) (1), (2), (3), (4), (5), (6) (1), (2), (3), (4), (5), (6), (7), (8), (9), (10), (11), (12), (13), (14), (15), (16), (17), (18), (19) 1) 2) 3) 4) 5) 6) 7) (, 2015). (5.36%), (2.93%). Sperry(2007),,,,

5 ,. (2005),,,,,,. (2015),,,,,,,,, 10. (2015).,,..,,. (Concept Mapping),,.. 1.? 2.? 3.? 4.?,, Kane Trochim(2007).,, (Goodyear et al., 2005).

6 (,, 2014).., , 34, 6.33., (Kane & Trochim, 2007). ( 4 ) (,,, 2011) (SD=4.14) 34 49, 8 (40.0%), 12 (60.0%) (SD=2.54) , 2.63 (SD=1.5) (SD=.69) (50%), 5 (25%), 4 (20%), 2 (10%), 2 (10%), 2 3.., 1 2., Kane Trochim(2007) 6,,,,,,, 6 5.,,. 2.

7 ,?.,. (,, 2012).. Giorgi 4 (Giorgi et al., 1985) , 197., ,, Trochim (1989) 100, (,, 2015)., , (Kane & Trochim, 2007)., ,. (similarity matrix), 18 (GSM: group similarity matrix). SPSS 21.0 (ALSCAL ), Stress. ALSCAL Stress Stress (, 2000, )., ALSCAL 2.,.

8 Stress Stress (Kane & Trochim, 2007), 72.6% (RSQ=.726) 2.. X 1, Y 2,,., 2 -. ALSCAL 2 Ward. 2 (centroid linkage) (average linkage) Ward (,, 2014).,, 10, , (value), ,

9 , 14,. 9,, ,. (,,, 2004)., 2, - (22 ) 4.,,, ,

10 .,,,. - 4, (1=, 2=, 3=, 4=, 5= ). 2., 15 (,, 2014;,, 2011). M SD 1. (6, M=3.62) (8, M=3.71) 2-1 (4, M=3.84) (4, M=3.58) 19. (,, ) CCTV

11 M SD 3. (3, M=3.50) (3, M=3.75) (12, M=3.67) 5-1 (3, M=3.98) (3, M=3.55) (6, M=3.57) , (15 30 ) (5, M=3.77) 34. (, )

12 M SD 7. (2, M=3.33) (14, M=3.67) 8-1 (3, M=3.55) (6, M=3.72) , (5, M=3.67) (4, M=3.93) 57., ,,,,, (3, M=3.66) 58.,

13 (M=3.98), 9. (M=3.93), 2-1. (M=3.84), 6. (M=3.77), 4. (M=3.75), 8-2 (M=3.72), 8-3 (M=3.67), 10. (M=3.66), 1. (M= 3.62), 2-2. (M= 3.58), 5-3 (M=3.57), 8-1 (M=3.55), 5-2 (M=3.55), 3. (M=3.50), 7. (M=3.33). 3,,..,,, , 57., (M=4.39, SD=.91). 15. (M=4.17, SD=1.09). 7. (M=4.11, SD= 1.13). 56. (M=4.06, SD=1.11). 21. (M=4.06, SD=1.11). 19. (,, ) (M=4.00, SD=1.28). 22. (M=4.00, SD= 1.13) ,,. 4 20, 60. 2, 10.,

14 Sperry(2007)., (2015). -.,, (, 2014),,,.,,., 5- (, 2002)., -, -,,. Brown(2012), Kitchener(1984), (, 2002), (, 2015),,,., 3., 10.,,,,,,,,,.,,..,., ( 2) (2015), (2007) (2005), (2011), (2002), Sperry(2007).,

15 Bronson(2010). ( 3) Sperry(2007). ( 4) (, 2007;, 2005) (,, 2011)., (2005). ( 5-1) (2015). (2015) ( 5-2), ( 5-3), ( 8), ( 9). (2012) ( ), (2011). ( 6) (2015), (2007), (2005), (2002), Sperry(2007). ( 8-2) (2015). ( 10) (2015), (2007). ( 1), ( 7), ( 8-1), ( 8-3). (, 2007;, 2005;, 2002), (Sperry, 2007), (, 2007;, 2005), (, 2002; Sperry, 2007), (Sperry, 2007).,,,.,.., ( 1), ( 8-1), ( 8-3), ( 9), ( 5-1), ( 5-2), ( 5-3), ( 8-2).., Nash(1993).

16 ,.,. 54.,.,,.,,. ( 2-1), ( 1),.,., Sperry(2007).,.., 4 20.,,.,,,.,.,, (2007).. (1), (2014). :. (1), ,, (2011).. :. (1999).. :., (2015).,,

17 . (3), (2006).. :., (2012).. (2), ,, (2014).. (3), (2010)..,.,, (2011).. :.,,,,,,,,,,, (2013).. :. (2014).. (1), (2005)..,., (2014).. (1), (2000).. :., (2011).. (3), (2012).. (1), 1-16.,, (2009).. (4), (2015)..,., (2011).. (3), , (2015).. (2), (2014).., ,,, (2015).. (2), (2004). :., (2011).. (2), , (2011). :. (2), (2005).. (3), ,, (2004). : (Concept Mapping). (1), (2012).. (2), , (2014).. (4), (2002).

18 . (4), (2002).. :. Bronson, M. K. (2010). Supervision of career counseling. In N. Ladany & L. J. Bradley(Ed.), Counselor supervision(4th ed) (pp ). NY: Routledge. Brown, D. (2012). Career information, career counseling, and career development(10th ed.). NJ: Pearson Education. Giorgi, A., Aanstoos, C. M., Fischer, W. F., & Wertz, F. J. (1985). Phenomenology and psychological research. Pittsburg, PA: Duquesne University Press. Goodyear, R. K., Tracey, T. J. G., Claiborn, C. D., Lichtenberg, J. W., & Wampold, B. E. (2005). Ideographic concept mapping in counseling psychology research: conceptual overview, methodology, and an illustration. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 52(2), Kane, M., & Trochim, W. M. K. (2007). Concept mapping for planning and evaluation. California: Sage. Kitchener, K. S. (1984). Intuition, critical evaluation and ethical principles: The foundation for ethical decisions in counseling psychology. The Counseling Psychologist, 12(3), Nash, L. L. (1993). Good intentions aside: A manager s guide to resolving ethical problems. Boston: Harvard Business School Press. National Career Development Association (2009). Career Counseling Competencies. Retrieved from associationdatabase.com/aws/ncda/pt/sd/news_article/3 7798/_self/layout_ccmsearch/true. Sperry, L. (2007). The ethical and professional practice of counseling and psychotherapy. Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon. Trochim, W. M. K. (1989). An introduction to concept mapping for planning and evaluation. Evaluation and Program Planning, 12(1), : : :

19 담학연구 Concept Mapping of Ethical Dilemma Perceived by University Career Counselors Sookmyung Women s University The purpose of this study were to investigate specific factors and conceptual structure of ethical dilemma perceived by university career counselors and to identify dimensions and clusters when recognizing the factors, and relative importance of the factors by using concept mapping method. Thus, after collecting the idea through questionnaires targeting 20 employment supporting counselors in four-years university nationwide, the total 60 final statements were elicited through the overall editing process. The participants rated the similarity and importance between the 60 statements for themselves, multidimensional scaling and hierarchical cluster analysis were used in order to identify dimensions and clusters of the factors in this study. As a result, a concept map consisted of 2 dimensions and 10 clusters formed. The results of this study were summarized as follows. First, the 2 dimensions, organizations -counselors responsibility factors and physical-relational working context factors were found, when the university career counselors perceived the ethical dilemma factors of this study. Second, the 10 clusters and 15 sub-clusters were showed, and contents of the 15 sub-clusters in order of importance were overburdened multiple job, uncertain employment contract with the organization, lack of counseling records security, lack of counselors competences, restriction of the autonomy, infringement of intellectual property rights, unclear roles and responsibilities of the counselors', avoiding cooperation with other professionals, inadequate counseling facilities, lack of personal counseling information protection, inadequate counseling setting, failure in justice of offering counseling service, discrepancy in organization value, failure of informed consent for personal information utilization, failure in following psychological tests ethics. This study is significant in that it increased ethical sensitivity of career counselor, organization and related workers in a university through investigating the ethical dilemma factors which university career counselors perceived in their doing the work. Additionally, the result of this study will provide a theoretical background for a preparation of a code of ethics, training program for the code of ethics, and ethics audit scale which is specific for career counseling in a university. Key words : University Career Counselors, Employment Supporting Counselors, Career Counseling Ethics, Ethical Dilemma, Concept Mapping

., (, 2000;, 1993;,,, 1994), () 65, 4 51, (,, ). 33, 4 30, 23 3 (, ) () () 25, (),,,, (,,, 2015b). 1 5,

., (, 2000;, 1993;,,, 1994), () 65, 4 51, (,, ). 33, 4 30, 23 3 (, ) () () 25, (),,,, (,,, 2015b). 1 5, * 4.,, 3,,, 3,, -., 3, 12, 27, 20. 9,,,,,,,,. 6,,,,,. 5,,,,.. * (2016),. (Corresponding Author): / / 303 Tel: 063-225-4496 / E-mail: jnj1015@jj.ac.kr ., (, 2000;, 1993;,,, 1994), 2000. 2015 () 65, 4 51,