Journal of Educational Innovation Research 2018, Vol. 28, No. 2, pp DOI: A Critical Reflecti

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Journal of Educational Innovation Research 2018, Vol. 28, No. 2, pp DOI: A Critical Reflecti"

진우 점
5 years ago
Views:

1 Journal of Educational Innovation Research 2018, Vol. 28, No. 2, pp DOI: A Critical Reflection on the Concept of Education Design Purpose & Method: The purpose of this study was to critically examine the concept of education design. The study reveals the essential attributes of the concept of design by analyzing the research literatures on design philosophy and the origins of design. In addition, the cases of accepting the concept of design in domestic educational studies were examined to clarify the primary characteristics of existing education studies. Based on the aforementioned set of analysis, this study suggests points to be considered reflectively in the concept of education design. Results: An analysis of design attributes showed three characteristics in common : comprehensive activity, the intersection of aesthetics and functionality, the power and ethics. Previous studies where design was studied in the context of instruction, curriculum, and school environment and other studies focusing on the education design itself showed the design in education, in most cases, was used as a strategic method with the aim of overcoming the problems of current education to bring about changes in future education. In conclusion, the results of a critical reflection on the concept of education design are as follows. First, a unique education design philosophy is needed. Second, education design research should not overlook the inherent dangers of design. Third, education design research should not be limited to pursuing the resultant aspects of design. Fourth, education design should not overlook the basic attributes of design, artistry and aesthetics. Conclusion: This study is meaningful in that it provides a basis for conceptual consensus that helps to solve the problem of vague and illegitimate use of the concept of educational design in education studies. This research is also expected to lead follow-up studies with themes such as education design philosophy and the role of education designers. Key words: Future education, Educational design, Instructional design, Design thinking, Universal design Corresponding Author: Bak, Ji-Won. Pusan National University, Dept. of Education, Busandaehak-ro 63 beon-gil, Geumjeong-gu, Busan, Korea, jiwon8669@daum.net

2 . BK21 +( Brain Korea 21 Plus) (2015).,. 2018,....,.,.,. (, 2015;,, 2011;, 2016;, 2016; 2018;, 2015;, 2013), (,, 2013;, 2017;,, 2015;, 2017;, 2017;,,, 2014;,,, 2017;, 2017). (, 2010;, 2015), (,, 2005;,,, 2002;,, 2009).,.,.,...

3 ,.,..,..,,,.,. (design),,,.., (design thinking)..,,,.,..,,,,,. (Walker, 1989: 42).., (designare). 1) / (out) de / (signum) signare

4 ,.. (imagination) (creativity) (Vygotsky, 1987).,. (,, 2008)., ( )., (, 2011: 41).,.. (, 2013;, 2013; Vial, 2010; Walker, 1989).,. 1) ( 15 desseing( ) disegno( )., (Walker, 1989: 43)...

5 ... 2)..,.,,,.,.,.,..? Vial (Vial, 2010: 63). 3).,,. 1) 종합적활동으로서디자인,, (, 2011: 53-55)..,. 2), (, 2004).,.. 3) Vial, ( ), ( ), ( ) (Vial, 2010).

6 (material)..,.. (2016: 200).. 2) 심미성과기능성의교집합.. Flusser(1990),. (techne)..,, (, 2016: 342) (ibid: 343).,. 3) 디자인의권력과윤리. (, ). (, 2011: 374).,..,,., (, 2013;, 2016).. (, 2016: 340)..

7 ....,,,.,.. 1) 수업및교육과정디자인,,.,, (, 2013). ( ),,, (,, 2010: 28).,.,. ADDIE Dick, Carey, Carey(2009). ADDIE (Analysis), (Design), (Development), (Implementation), (Evaluation). (Gagné, Wager, Golas, & Keller, 2005). Dick, Carey, Carey(2009),,,,

8 (systems approach).,,,,,,,,, 10,.,. (curriculum design).,, (Print, 1993). Print(1993),.,,,,,..,., (2007),, (2011), (Design-based Research). (2015).,,.,. (2015),,,,.,,,. (2016).,,,,,,,,,,.

9 . (2013),,. (2018),.,. ( ),.,, ,,,,. 2) 디자인사고와교육,.,,, (,, 2008). Martin (2009),.?, (Abduction), (Abductive logic) (, 2016; Martin, 2009; Novoru, 2010)., ( ).,

10 , (Martin, 2009)., (Novoru, 2010, ; Rowe, 1987).., IDEO 5, 4).., -.. (,, 2013;,,, 2014), - (, 2017;,, 2015;, 2017;, 2017;,,, 2017;, 2013, 2017).,, (2014)..,,, STEAM, SW,, 4) Riverdale, IDEO,,, 2014;, 2017,. p.450,,,,, SCAMPER,,,,, ( ), ( ), ( ),,,.

11 -. (2017) STEAM, (IDEO) 5 STEAM 3. STEAM. -. IDEO. 3) 학교공간디자인및유니버설디자인,,, 1960~70 (,, 2013)., (, 2010;, 2015;, 2014). 5),. (2015).,,. (2014),,,. 5) ,,,.,, (, 2015).

12 .,., (Universal Design). (, ) (, 2008). 7 (Universal Design Kenkyukai, 2005).,,,,,,,,,,,,,. (Universal Design for Learning: UDL). UDL (,,,,, 2014),, (,, 2009). (,, 2005;,,, 2002)., - (,, 2009).,, (,, 2016).

13 ,,,.,,,, (2014),.,,., (wicked problem).,,,,.,. (2017). ( ) ( ).,,, / /,.,,,.,,., BK21 + (Brain Korea 21 Plus). BK21 +..,,, ( BK21PLUS, 2015). BK21 +,,.

14 ,,,,,,,.,,,. ( ( ),,,,,.,.,,,.,..

15 .,.,... (,,,, ),...,,.,...., (schooling).,..,,,,.,...,

16 ...., (,, )...,. 6).,,,..,.,.,,,.,..,,. 6) Mcluhan(1964).. ( )..

17 -.,,..,.,.,..,.,..,.,.. ( ), ( ), ( )..,.,.,...,.,

18 .,.,.,.,...,.,..,,..,..,. (redesigning).,,.,,.,. (Buchanan, 1995). (Buchanan, 1995),.. Borgman(1995),., (, 2017).

19 .,.,..,.,,,.,.,,,.,,,,.,.,.,..,.,.,,.,...,,.

20 , (2013).. (1), (2008). (Universal Design) (2015).. (3), , (2011). (DBR). (2), , (2005).. (2), , (2016).. (3), , (2008) ,,,, (2014).. (4), (2013). :. (2016).. (1), (2011). 3D :.. (2016). :. (2011). :. (2016).. (4), (2018).. (3), , (2007).. (1), , (2013).. (1), (2015).,,. (3), , (2010). :.

21 BK21PLUS BK21PLUS (2015). :. (2017).. (16), (2010).. (4), , (2008).., , (2015). (Design Thinking). (6), (2017)...,, (2002).. (3), (2016). :. (2017). STEM -Design Thinking. (1), (2013)... (2015)...,, (2014).. (2), ,, (2017).. (2), (2004).., (2013).. (2), (2017).., ,,,,,,,,, (2014). - J D. (2), (2017)..

22 , (2009). (UDL). (1), (2015) Borgman, A. (1995)., Buchannan, R. & Margolin, V.(1995). Discovering Design. (2002). :. Brigitte, B. M. (2008). Design Management. (2008). :. Dick, W., Carey, L., & Carey, J. O. (2009). The Systematic Design of Instruction. 7th Edition.,, (2009). :. Flusser, V. (1990). Vom Stand der Dinge. (2003). :. Mcluhan, M. (1964). Understanding Media : the Extensions of Man. (2011). :. Konno, N. (2010). (2012). :. Buchannan, R. (1995). Buchannan, R. & Margolin, V. (1995). Discovering Design. (2002). :. Gagné, R. M., Wager, W. W., Golas, K. C., & Keller, J. M. (2005). Principle of Instructional Design. 5th Edition.,,, (2007). :. Martin, R. L. (2009). The Design of Business. (2010). :. Print, M. (1993). Curriculum Development and Design. 2nd Edition.,,,,, (2006). :. Universal Design Kenkyukai (2005). Universal Design Study. (2006). :. Vial, S. (2010). Court traité du design. (2012). :. Vygotsky, L. S. (1987). The Collective Works of L. S. Vygotsky. (2014). :. Walker, J. A. (1989). Design history and the history of design. (1995). :. : / : / :

23 :.,.. :,,,.,,,..,.,.,.,. :.,.

Journal of Educational Innovation Research 2017, Vol. 27, No. 2, pp DOI: : Researc

Journal of Educational Innovation Research 2017, Vol. 27, No. 2, pp.251-273 DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.21024/pnuedi.27.2.201706.251 : 1997 2005 Research Trend Analysis on the Korean Alternative Education