๋ ธ์ฌ๊ฐํ - ๋ฏธ๋๋ฅผ์ํ์ ํ ํ๊ตญ๋ ธ๋์ฐ๊ตฌ์
. :.,? 1. 30 2. 3. 4. ILO OECD., 1. 2. 3. 4.., 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6..,. : 1. : 2. : 10 3. : 4. : :. (1996.4.24. ). (1996.7.9. ). (1996.7.11. ). 3 (1997.3.10.).. (1997.6.17. )
. 21,,., 21,,.,. :... 1997 9
1996 4 24...,.. 5 9.. 3..,... 1....... 1997 9
. :...,,.,,..?.,?.,., ( )..,.... 1960 1995 1 1.. 21. 21,..,.?.......?.
...,,,.. ( ).,.. (zero sum)... (positive sum)....,...,,.........,. 1980 90,,,......,, (win-win).
.,? 1. 30... 1987. 1987 6 29, 1987. 1) 1987.... 1960 22 1970 47 1980 100. 1980.. 1970.,,. 1970 10. 1970. 1970.. 1980 5..
< -1> 2) 1987 1987 6 29... 1 200 1987 3,749. 1987... 1987 6 94 8 127 1989 193..,. 1986 88 12%. 4 5 2.. 1987.
..... -2 1993,, ( ) 2. 1995 2 ( ). 1980. 1989 193 1995 161 ( -1 ). 6 29 1989.. 1990. 1987. 1990.., 1990. 1987 3,749 1989 1,616, 1992 234. 1995 88 1996 85. ( -3 ). 1,000.. ( ) ( ).,
-1-3 -4 1,000........
.... -5. (, 1995) ' ' 10%. ' ' ' ' 56.5% 54.6%. -5..,,.... 1,541 (1996. 5.) 90.5% ' ' ", "...,,...,,,.,,,.
.......... 2.. 21 ' ' ' '..,...,..,...,.. -2.... (lose-lose).
-2,.. (win-win). -2....,....,.,.,. ( ) = = =,...,.,.., 'hungry spirit'.,..
-6 3.. 1987 89 " 3 ".. 1953 1989 8. 1953,,,...... 4 5 16, 3 3 ( ).,,. 1963,,,.. 4 1971. 1973... 1974. 5 1980,,., 1 8.
,, 3,. 3,. 1986 3. 6 1987,,. 1989 3 ( 44 ). 1992 1994.. -7.,., 3, '3 '.. 3, 3. 1980 1987 '3 '(,, )
.. '3 ',,,... 4. ILO OECD. ILO ILO( ) " " 1919. ILO UN 3.,,.,,. ILO,, ILO. ILO " ". ILO.. ILO...,.. ILO ( 87 ), ( 98 ), ( 29 105 ), ( 138 ), ( 111 ). ILO... ILO ILO 1996 173. 1991 12 9 152 1996 83 ILO 3.. ILO. ILO ILO. ILO
ILO. ILO... ILO 1993 3,, 3 11. 1996 6 3,., ( )...OECD... OECD 2 1948 (OEEC) 1961 18. OECD 20 (1964 ), (1969 ), (1971 ), (1973 ), 1990 (1994 ), (1995 ), (1996 ), (1996 ) (1996 ) 29.,,,. OECD 18% 1994 GNP 81%, 69%, 70% 1 GDP 20.106. OECD WTO( ). UR,, OECD.,,, OECD,,,,. OECD 1982 OECD 1989. OECD 1991 3 1992 OECD 5 (1993. 7.) OECD 1996 11 4. 1995 3 OECD 1996 10 11 OECD 29. OECD. 1995 GDP 10, 1 GNP 1. OECD,,,.
-8 (1995 ) OECD (ELSAC)., 3,. ELSAC. ELSAC OECD. OECD (TUAC) OECD " ". OECD ' '. OECD..OECD OECD,,.. OECD.. OECD,,...,.
OECD.. TUAC ELSAC. OECD. OECD ' ' ' ', OECD...,. 1. 1996 2 15. 21.. 21. 2 23 ( ), ( ), ( ), ( ), ( ) ASEM (3 1 ) (4 13 ).. 4 13 4 17 ( ). 4 24. 4 24,,, 200 21..... 21.,. ' ', ' '.,.. ' ',.,. ' ' ' '.,.,. ' '.
' '.,.,.. -1 5 2.. 1996 5 9 ( ). 5, 10, 10 30.,,. -2
-3 4,,,, 30. (20 )... 21 5,,, 3. 3.. 21,... 1 (1996. 5. 6.), 2 (1996. 7. 12.), 3 (1997.1 1998.2). 1.
-4 5 18,.., (71.6%), (45.8%),,,. 10 9 (90.5%).., (5 27 ), (6 3 ), (6 5 ). 5 18 6 23, 6 14 20. 1 90,, 20.. 5 20,. '
( )', ' ( )', ' ', ' ', ' '. 5 28.,. 5 23.. 1996 7. 5.. 7 9.. ' ',.. ' '.,. ' ',. ' ' ' '...,,. ' '. ' '..... 7 11..
7,..,..,.,..,..,..,.. 7.( ). 3.. 7 2.. 1.. 8 13 6 ( ). 8 14 9 8 3.. 2 5 9.,,. 8 14 (,, ).... 8 14 21. 8 22 5.
9 3. 9 7,.,,,,,,.. 9 19 7.... 5 4. (veto). 9 23 10 1.... 10 1.,. 10 7 10. ' ', ' ', ' ', ' ', ' ', ' ', ' ', ' ', ' (, )' 9. 10 18. 10 25 12.........,
. 8 14 1 150. 110.... 40 7.,,,,,... (,, ) 10....... 10 30 4.. 11 4 7 148 107 41. 11 12. 6.. 1 1 6.,,,,.,,, 1 ( ). 1.,
3,,,,,,.,,,. ( ).,,, 4, 2. 4. 11 13 14 (, ).. 8 (,, ). (, )...... ( ). 12 3.., (, ). 12 10., 1,,,, ( ). ' ' ' '.. < > ' ' ' '.,.... 2.
12 26 4 11. 3..,,.. 12 26 57. 27. 12 27 ' '. 12 31, (1997 ). 1 3 1 7 4. 14 15.,,... OECD ILO. 1997 1 21. 2 17 3 1., ( )., 2 28. 3 10 4 ( ). 12 26 4.. 1996 4 < > 9. 1996 4....
< -5>
< > 1.
2.
3. (1996. 12. 10.)
., 1997 3..,,.,.
,.,. 1., 3, 2,,,,.. < -1>,,.,,,.,,,. ( 2 ), ( 8 ).
. < -2> 3 5. ILO OECD,. ( ' ' ), " 2001 "..,,...., OECD..,, ( : 7 1 ) ( 3 2 ; 81 2 ).
. 3 < -3> 3,. ( 12 2) ( 13 2), ( 27 ) 3,,,,,., 3. ILO,. 40,,, 3..,.
< -4> ( 15 ),, ' ' (1995. 4. 25. 68207-117)..,.,,.,. 43 1, " ". ' ' ( 1993. 2. 9. 91 21381 ),., 43 2, " ",.. < -5> 2 ( 32 1 ).. 1 ( 35 1 ).
. 2., 3 (,,,, ) 5 ( ).. < -6>,.,. 12, ( 1 ), ( 2 ), ( 3 ).,.. ILO. ' ' ( 2 4 ).,., 2 4 " ".,
. ( 12 5 ), ( 3 3 ). ( 87 ), ( 85 2 ).. < -7>, 100 2 ( 24 1 ).,...,.,., ( 21 2 ). < -8> ( 21 ),
,.,. 10 ( 21 ), 30 ( 21 3 ),. 34 3,,. ( 31 3 ),.,,.. < -9> ( 85 5 ). ( 46 ). (1995. 3. 23. 92 14 ).,..
< -10>, ( 30 1 ), ( 30 2 )..,. 3,.,. 2..,,.,,.. 2.
< -11>,.,. (1989. 5. 23. 87 2132),,,. (1991. 12. 10. 91 8647),,. ( ' ' ) 31 1, '. 31 2,. 3,,.. < -12>
1 8 1 44, 1 ( 47 2). 2 1. 2, 2 44 48 ( 50 1 ). 2, 1 3 40 2 4 48, 8 44 4. 50 2, 1. 1 44 56 12. (, ).,,,,. 1, 1,, ( ),.,. ( 50 3 ),.,. 1 1 1, 26 52, 6 24, 1..
< -13>., 1.,,,.,.. < -14>,.,,,,, ( 26 1 ).,
. ( ) ( ).. < -15>,,. 56 1 ",., ". 2 " ", ( 4 ).. < -16> 12.,,.
58 1 ",,,,,,,,,,, ". ( 28 1 ). 12, ( 58 1,2 ).. < -17>,.., 21 " 1 1 "., ILO 1994 " ( ) ". ( 25 1 ), ILO,,, EU., ( 9 1, 1 ). 25 3 "1 ". "4 (4 ) 1 15 " ( 9 2 ).,, ( 9 3 )..
< -18>,. 34 3 " 1 ",..,..,.. 34 4 ", ", 11. 96 5,,.,..
< -19>. 60 " ".. 1. 1987, 5,.. < -20> 70%, 70% ( 45 1 ). 70% " ", 70%. 3...,,.
. < -21>,.,,. 2 ",,,, ". (1990. 5. 15. 90 357)., ( ) ( ). ( ' ' ),,,,,, ( 2 5 ). ' ', ' ', (, ).. ( 34 )..,. 37 1 ",
< -22> ", 2 " ".,.,., (1990. 5. 15. 90 357)..,... < -23>. ( 10, 15 )., 3.,
,. ( ). 10, 15, 10, 15 ( 54 )... < -24>.,,,.,.,,.,.,..,.,,
( 42 2, 38 2 ). ( 38 3 ).. < -25>,.,,,,,, ( 71 1 ). ' ' ( 62 3 ). ( ) ( ),,,,, ( ) 2000.. ( 72 ),.,.,,
20 30 ( 76, 77 )... < -26>. ( 12 2 ),., ( 41 2 ),.. < -27> ( 34 1 ). 30 ( 34 2 3 ),.,,.
. ' ' ( 2 5 ),. 4.. < -28> " ".. ", " ( 33 1 ),. (1993. 4. 27. 91 12257). ( 29 1 ),.. < -29>,. 24 2 "
", 81 4., 2002, ( 6 ). 1 1,500, ( 46 2) ( ). 2 2,000 ( 90 ). 2001,.,..,... < -30>,.., (1992.3.27. 91 36307),.,,. (1995. 12. 21. 94 26721),., " ".,
., ( 44 1 ). ( 44 2 ).,,.. < -31>,.. 3 4,., ( 1993. 6. 8. 92 42354 ). 2 4,,,.,..
< -32>,.,. 32 3,, 3., " ( ). ". 90.,.. < -33>.. 10. 3
( 12 1 ). ( 12 4 ),.., ( 12 3 ). ( 8 )... < -34> 13 15,.., 13 15. ILO ( 138 ), 15. 15, ( 62 1 ). ( 2 ). 15 18, 1 7, 1 42, 1 1, 1 6 ( 67 ). ( 55 ). ( 50 3 ). ( 51 1 ). 5.,..
< -35>., 2, ( 13, 16 ).,. ( 87 ).,,,,, ( 33 1 ).,, ( 33 1 2 )., ( 49 )..,. ( ' ' ) 1 ( 9 3 ). ( 2 2 ),., ( 4 1 2 ).
. < -36> ( 6 2 3 ), ( 6 3 4 ). ( 9 2, 11 1 )..
< -37>,,,.,,. 6 4,,. ( 6 3 ),,. ( 13 1 ), ( ) ( 21 1 ), ( ) ( 21 2 3 4 ).. 17,..,. 8 1, 8 2..( -39, -40 )
, < -38> < -39>. 10 ( 6 1 ), 7 20 ( 6 2 ).
< -40> 6...,,., 30 ( 4, 2 ). 50, 50 ( 4, 2 ),..,. ( ) ( 6 2 ).
< -41>,. ( ' ' ) 6 2,,. ( 3 1 )...,,, < -42>, ( 20 ). 3 2 ( 14 ). ( 23 ), 1,000 ( 30 2 )..
< -43>.,,,,,, ( 20 ).,,,,,,,,,, ( 19 1 ).. < -44>. 21 1,,,., ( 21 3 ). ( 21 3 ), 500 ( 31 )..
< -45>. 24 1,, 3. ( 24 2 ), 1,000 ( 30 3 ).. < -46>. 28 1., 1 ( 28 2 ), ( 3 )., 10 4 ( 11 1 ).,,,,,, ( 12 ).
., 1996 4 1..... 1997 4 10 2. 5 2. 1 3 (1 ), (2 ), (3 ). 5 9..
< -1>
< -2> 2. 10 20...,,... 2002,.. 2002.,
...... ( )...,.... 1997 6 17, ( )..,.,...... 2002. 2002.....,,.. : 1. :.. 1980,
1990, 1..,..,,,,. 1990. (IMD) 1994 97 4 1,,,. -1. :...,,,..,,,,,,. (Mission Statement),,., (strategic partnership).... (Just-In-Time
:JIT),.. (flat), (lean), (flexible), (innovative). -2..,.,. (Self-Directed Teams : SDT). 5 15.,.. QC. -2. - (empowerment). -. -. -.
-. -. -,. -.,,. (empowerment).. (manager) (supervisor) (team leader), (coordinator),, (facilitator). -3 Becton, Dickinson & Company.,,. (facilitator). -3 Becton, Dickinson & Company.,,...,....
,..,.. 5%..,,,,...... ( ) ( )... ( )... ' ' ' '. D. Q. Mills J. McCormick (master-servant), (management control), (unionmanage-ment counterbalancing) (competitiveorien-tation), 1980. < -1>.,..,.
< -1>. 1980,..... Kochan, Katz McKersie KKM < -2>,. < -2>..,,. 1980...
< -2>.,..... (mission),..,.. ( ),,,. 1980. QC,,,
,,,,,,.?,. 1985 84%, 90% ' ' (The 1985 National Survey of Employee Attitudes, Business Week and Sirota and Alper Associates, 1985. 9.). Princeton Survey Research Center,,,,,,,.,. GTE Bruce Carswell Dunlop Commission. ". (empowered employees),,,,.". AFL-CIO The American Workplace : A Labor Perspective. " ( )..". 1992. - -.. 10 1993 3 24, ( ' ' )..,. 11, 6. 1994 5,
1994 12. 15,. (National Labor Relations Act : NLRA) 8(a)2. 8(a)2.. 2.. 2. : 10. 1979.... 1971, 1972 1974.. (1981) 1982, 1984, 1988 1990., 1980...,. 1906 4.,,. (wildcat strike),,,.,. (, )., 1960 70. 1963 376 1979 518..,.,,.,.
.. 1906 80%.,...10 1) 1971. 1979.,. 1.,..,. 1979. "... ",. 1980. 1980 1974 79 2 2,, 1982 5 : " " - - - 2 -.
1906.. 1984 5 10 1988 - - - - - - 1990 2 ( ). 1971.. (1985 87 ) 11% (1985 88 4% ). 1970 20% 1990 5%.. 1980 56.3%(OECD ) 1992 41.3%.. 10. 1982
< >..,,. 1) Charles G. Hanson, "Taming the Trade Unions : A Guide to the Thatcher Government's Employment Reforms. 1980 90" (,, 1992. 32-37 ).
3. : 1970 1980. < >. 1950 1960. 2%. 1970 1970. 1983. 1983 Bob Hawke (ACTU) 1983 ' '. 1983 86,,,,,,,. ' '.... 1983 2 ' '. 1986. 1983 86... 1987. (1987 90 )
.. 1987 (Restructuring and Efficiency Principle).. 1987 2. 1 10 11 6. 2 4%.. 2 1 2, ' '. 1988 (Structural Efficiency Principle), 1987.. 1986 1990. 1990 1992 1993. 1992 7,.... 1992. 1993 3 1983 Keating. 1904 1993 (Industrial Relations Reform Act. 1993).. " " 1993 " ".,..
1996. (Workplace Relations Bill). 1996 2 18 (Shadow Minister for Industrial Relations) Peter Reith., 1996 3 23. 1997 1.. 1991 (Employment Contract Act. 1991).. 20. (Australian Workplace Agreements : AWA)...... 3. 4. :. 1)' ' ' '. 1923, 1938, ( ) 1977. 1990 8 31 ' ', ( 30 ). 1992 13 92 ( ). 1977,,,,,,,,,.,,
. "." ( 20 ), ' '., ( 77 78 ), ( ) ( 91 93 ),, ( 8 ).,. ' '. 2) 1994. 1994. ( 3 2 1 ) 1957 6 ( 1 ), EU 1975, 1976,,, EG (EG-Anpassungsgesetz). EU,,, 2 1994 (1994. 9. 1 ). 1994 10 " " ( 2 2 2 ),.., 28 1994 (Arbeitzeitgesetz). 1993 11 23 EC (93/104/EC).., 6 24 1 8 1 10 ( 3 ). ( 7 1 ). ( 7 1 2 ).,,,.( 13 5 ).. 1994 7 26 (Gesetz über arbeitsrechtliche zur Beschäftigungsförderung).
,., 1994 10 (Arbeit sförderungsggesetz : AFG).,.,.,.. 1) 1987 1993 1969 1970. 1985.... 1987. 1987 5 40, 1997 4 ( 32 ).. 1947 4 1 1 3 ( 32 4). 1993 6 1 1 3 1. 1987 (core time). ( 38 2 4, 5 ). 1993 5,.,,.,.,,...
2) 1993 1993. 1993. 1994 60, 60,,. 1991 1994 1999 4. 1995 4 ' '.., 1, 5..., 1987., 1985 1987, 1993,.., 1996 12,,, 16 26.. ' ',... (1996.4.24. ) - 21 -,!! 21., 21.,.
21,.,.... 21.....,...,! 21.,....,.....,....,..
....,.,....,! 21............, 21.,!!.,. 21...
,.,. 21. 21.,..
. (1996.7.9. ) 1.,,............. 2.,...........
.. 3.,,.,....,.,...,...
. (1996.7.11. ) 1... (Win-Win)........,,... 2.., - ( ) - ( ). - ( )
- ( ). - ( ). - ( ), - ( ).. - ( ),, - ( ). - ( ). - ( ) - ( ) - ( ). - ( ) - ( ). - ( ). - ( ) - ( ),. - ( ).. -( ) -( ). -( )
. -( ), -( ). -( ). -( ).
. 3 (1997. 3. 10),, 3. 3,..,..,,.,..,., 21. 3.,. 3.,,.,. 5.
,,.,..,.. 3. 1997. 3. 10
.!.. 21....!. 1953,.. 21. 21. < >. 20 ' ' 21 ' ',..!.. ' '.. ' ' ' '.... 1997 3 12
. (1997. 6. 17 ) [ ] 21,,,.,,,.,,.... 1. -. -. -. -. -. 2.. -. -,. -... -,,,
-. -.... - -,.. - -,,,, -,, - - - - -' ' - - - -,.
-.. -., -,., -