Journal of Educational Innovation Research 2017, Vol. 27, No. 2, pp DOI: A Life History Rese

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Journal of Educational Innovation Research 2017, Vol. 27, No. 2, pp DOI: A Life History Rese"

효연 천
5 years ago
Views:

1 Journal of Educational Innovation Research 2017, Vol. 27, No. 2, pp DOI: A Life History Research on the Reconceptualization of Political Neutrality of a School Teacher Purpose: The aim of this paper was to reconceptualize the political neutrality of schooling and school teacher in Korea through politically interpreting pedagogical experience, which is derived from the life trajectory of a history teacher. Method: This paper applied a life history research to illuminate the political neutrality in the pedagogical story of a school teacher. In addition, this paper analyzed the narratives and documents of the participant via a holistic content approach. Results: Two prominent results in terms of political neutrality of a school teacher are a pursuit of professionality and autonomy in history education through alternative educational activities: realizing zeitgeist, and the reconceptualization on the political neutrality of school teacher: from normative and legal perspective to practical approach. Conclusion: The results of this paper would be able to be a catalyst to understand and reconceptualize the political neutrality of schooling and school teacher in Korea. Key words : political neutrality of school teacher, ideological state apparatuses, conscientization, praxis Corresponding Author: Lee, Dong-Sung. Jeonju National University of Education, Dept. of Elementary Education, Seohakro 50, Wansangu, Jeonju, Jeonbuk, Korea, dslee@jnue.ac.kr

2 .?,?, (, 2015)., (, ) (, 2015)., (, 2015: 2)., (, 2016: 36-41). (, 2015)., (, 2016)., ( ) ( ) (, 2009: 55)., (, 2016)..,.,. (2006.1),,, (, 2012: 140).,, (, 2015).,, (, )?,?

3 , (,, 2014;, 2010).,,, (,, 2014).,,, (, 2010; Caiden, 1997)., (Matheson et al., 2007;, 2010),. (, 2015;, 2011;, 2013;, 2015;, 2016;, 2010;, 2010), (, 2011;, 2010;, 2016)., (, 2009, 2011;, 2016) ( ) (, 2009)., (, 2009;,, 2012;, 2016)., (, 2009), (, 2009;, 2011).,,, (, 2016: 36-41).,.,,., ( ), (,, 2012: ). ( )

4 ..,?,?.. ( ), (, 2015: 4)., (, ) (, 2012: 139),.,, ( 31 4 )., ( 7 2 ).,, ( 6 1 )., ( 14 4 ).,, ( )., ( 57 ). (, 2012: 139). (, 2011: 26; Christensen, 1991; Thompson, 1985; West, 2005).,, (, 2011; Levitan, 2007; Thompson, 1885)., ( ) ( ) ( ),,

5 (, 2011: 27; Svara, 2009: 1037).,, (, 2011; Sossin, 2005: 25)., Althusser(1971: ) ( ),.,. Althusser(1971: ), (state apparatus) (RSA, ISA). (Repressive State Apparatus, RSA),,,,,, RSA ( )., (Ideological State Apparatus, ISA) ISA( ), ISA( ), ISA, ISA, ISA( ), ISA( ), ISA(,, ), ISA(,, ), ISA RSA (Janik, 2015; Leitch, 2001)., ISA ISA (Althusser, 1971: ), ISA,, ( ) (, ). (Ferretter, 2006; Sadati, 2013)., (illusion), (Bertens, 2001).,, (, 2001: 68). Althusser(1971: 176), ISA (, ) (interpellation) (Alloggio, 2012: 83)., (Althusser, 1971: 168).,, (mirror structure) (Althusser, 1971: 164).,,,, (, 2001;

6 Alloggio, 2012; Sadati, 2013). (, 2001: 76). Althusser,,, (, 1996: 173).,., ( 55 ;, 2012: 140), ( 58 ;, 2012: 140).,. ( ) ( ),., (, 2015;, 2011;, 2013;, 2015;, 2016;, 2010;, 2010) ( ), (, 2011;, 2010;, 2016).,, (,, 2014;, 2011;, 2010).,, (, 2010). ( ), (, 2010)., (, 2011). (,, ), (, 2010: 72-74).., (, 2009,

7 2011;, 2016) (, 2009).,,,, ( ), (, 2015)., (, 2016)., (, 2016)., (, 2011: 25)., (, 2009;,, 2012;, 2016).. (2009), ( ),., (2012),,.,, (,, 2012: 239)..,, ( ) (,, 2012: 239).,,.,..

8 . (life history research).,,,., (IRB). (1 : /1, 2 : /5 37, 3 : /1 23 ), , (,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ). Lieblich, Tuval-Mashiach, & Zilber(1998) (holistic-content approach). (Lieblich, Tuval-Mashiach, & Zilber 1998). :, :. : :,,,,, ISA( ) :.

9 (trustworthiness).,,., (, )., (rapport),,.,.,..,.. ( ) (44, ) (life story) ,.. ( ) 7 ( ), ,

10 ., ( ) ,. (, ).,. 1987,., 2,.,, (1 12 ).,..,.,.,., ( 5 ). 3,.,.,, !. 3, !. 1800,.,.

11 ..,....,,.,. 3., ,,..,, , , ( ).,.. 1.

12 .,. ( )...,., ,,, ,. 50,., ( ) ,., , ( ) ( 3, ) (33 ).,,, ,,.,,.,,. ( ),

13 3( 3) (2008, 3 ).,..... ( )., (, 2002: 2-3). ( ), ( ), ( ) ( 3, )., 1999 ( ),..,., ( 3, ).,

14 ,.,,,., (1.? 2.? 3.! 4. 5.? 6.! 7.? 8.!),., (,,,,, ).....!...,. 10, 40 (, 2 )..,..,! (, 3 )., (NIE),,.,

15 , (,,, ). 4.19,.,.,,..., ( , ).., 1894,,, ,..... (, (2008) ).,.,. Freire(1995) (praxis). Freire(1995),,,

16 , (, 2014: ).....,. ( ) ( ). (, 3 ). (,, ) 7, ( ) , 4 2,, 8 1 ( 7 :,,, 7.) , , , Althusser(1971), (RSA),.. ( :,,,,

17 , ISA : ).., ( ),.,,,,,,.,,,.,,..,,. ( ),,,.., 7 (,, ) ,,....,,.! ( , ).,..,

,...,..... (2008. 09. 03, ).,,.... ( ),,.. (2008. 03. 15, ).

18 ,...,..... ( , ).,,.... ( ),,.. ( , ). :

19 .,,,.,,.,..!.,,,,. (, 2 ).,.....!.. ( ). ( ),., (,, 2008: 9-10)., ( ),. 7., 7.,,,.,,,.

20 ,,, 1., (ISA). Althusser(1971),,. (Neo-Marxism) Althusser(1971) Gramsci(1995). Gramsci(1995) (hegemony),, (, 2014: 128). Gramsci(1995),.,.,,. (ISA), (RSA)., Althusser(1971) RSA ISA,,.,,,,,.,.,,,.,.,,.,

21 .. < > (., ).,.,.., (,, 2012: 238;, 2009)..,

22 .,., (,,, ).,..,.,. (, 2015;, 2006). ( Hatch ) (, 2015;,, 2012: 241).,., ( ).,, (, 2013;, 2016).,,.,.,, (Beutelsbacher Konsens).,, (, 2016).,,, (, 2016)..,,,,.

23 ,, (,, 2014).,..,,,,., (Platon).., (2014). : (2014). (2 ). :. (2015).. (1), (2001).,, :. (1), (2011). :. (4), (2013). :. (1), (2015).. (1), (2015).. (1), (2016). : (1), (1996) (2010).. (2), (2006). : (2009). :.

24 (4), , (2012). :. (3), (2002) :. (2010).. (1), (2012).. (2), (2016)., (2016). (EVLN) : ( ), ( ) (2008). :!. ( ) (2008)., : ( ).. (2009) (2011).. (1), (2011).. (3), (2016) Alloggio, S. (2012). The reproduction of control: Notes on Althusser s notion of ideological state apparatuses(isas) and the use of Machiavelli. African Yearbook o Rhetoric, 3(1), Althusser, L. (1971). Ideology and ideological state apparatuses. In L. Althusser (ed). Lenin and philosophy, and other essay. (Trans.) Brewster, B. London: New Left Books. Bertens, H. (2001). Literary theory: The basics. London: Routledge. Caiden, G. E. (1997). The difference between neutral and mindless. PA Times, 20(1), 1. Christensen, T. (1991). Bureaucratic roles: Political loyalty and professional autonomy. In M. Maor & J. Lane (eds). Comparative public administration volume : Analytical frameworks and critiques. pp Vermont: Ashgate Publishing Company. Ferretter, L. (2006). Louis Althusser. Oxford: Routledge. Freire, P. (1995). ( ). :. Gramsci, A. (1995). Further selections from the prison notebook. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.

25 Janik, M. (2015). Louis Althusser, on the reproduction of capitalism: Three reading strategies. Décalages, 1(4), 1-8. Leitch, V. B. (2001). The Norton anthology of theory and criticism. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, Inc. Levitan, D. M. (2007). The neutrality of the public service. In N. M. Riccucci (ed). Public personnel Administration and labor relations. pp New York: M.E. Sharpe. Lieblich, A., Truval-Mashiach, R. & Zilber, T. (1998). Narrative research: Reading, analysis and interpretation. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Matheson, A., Weber, B., Manning, N., & Arnould, E. (2007). Study in the political involvement in senior staffing and in the delineation of responsibilities between ministers and senior civil servants. OECD working papers on public governance, 2007/6, OECD doi: / Sadati, S. S. (2013). The influence of ideological state apparatuses in identity formation: Althusserian reading of Amiri Baraka s In memory of radio. International Journal of English and Literature, 4(10), doi: /ijel Sossin, L. (2005). Speaking truth to power: The search for bureaucratic independence in Canada. University of Toronto Law Journal, 55, Svara, J. H. (2009). Introduction to the symposium: The nature of public professionalism and the future of ASPA. Public Administration Review, 69(6), Thompson, D. F. (1985). The possibility of administrative ethics. Public Administration Review, 45(5), West, W. F. (2005). Neutral competence and political responsiveness: Uneasy relationship. The Policy Studies Journal, 33(2), : / : / :

26 : ( ). :., Lieblich, Tuval-Mashiach, & Zilber(1998). : :, :. :,.

Journal of Educational Innovation Research 2016, Vol. 26, No. 3, pp.1-16 DOI: * A Study on Good School

Journal of Educational Innovation Research 2016, Vol. 26, No. 3, pp.1-16 DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.21024/pnuedi.26.3.201612.1 * A Study on Good School and School Evaluation Purpose: This study was to examine